Take it into the room

What does this work illuminate for you?

Ask Sebastian about this book. He answers from the library and names his sources.

Get the letter

A Dream About Epidaurus

C. A. Meier, a psychiatrist who practiced in Switzerland from 1936, co-founded the C.G. Jung Institute in Zurich and was its president until 1957. He became convinced of the need to study ancient incubation while working in a psychiatric clinic, where even psychotic patients showed him what he calls the “self-healing tendency of the psyche.” Healing Dream and Ritual is the 1989 English version of Der Traum als Medizin (1985), which grew out of his Antike Inkubation und moderne Psychotherapie (1949).

The first chapter, “The Divine Sickness,” asks whether modern psychotherapy has ancient prototypes. Meier’s first clue was Galen, who called himself the therapeutes of his fatherly god Asclepius, a word Meier takes in its old sense of an attendant of a cult. His second came from a woman patient who dreamed a single sentence: “The best thing he created is Epidaurus.” She slowly recalled the sanctuary of Asclepius she had once seen, and Meier calls the whole book “a somewhat detailed amplification of the key word “Epidaurus”” from that dream.

The Divine Sickness

In antiquity, Meier argues, sickness was the effect of a divine action and could be cured only by a god. Of that god he writes, “He was the sickness and the remedy.” An oracle of Apollo gives the book its principle, “He who wounds also heals” (ho trosas iasetai). Telephus was healed by rust from the spear that wounded him, Apuleius’s Psyche by the arrow of Cupid that wounded her, and Chiron, who taught Asclepius medicine, was himself incurably wounded by the arrows of Hercules. Meier reads this theme as an ancient prototype of the training analysis every analyst must undergo. Galen fits the pattern, since Asclepius cured him of an abscess in a dream.

Epidaurus, Asclepius and Serapis

The sanctuary at Epidaurus was active from about the sixth century B.C. to the third century A.D., and new sanctuaries were founded by carrying one of its sacred serpents, the god in animal form, to the new site. In the Roman account the serpent came ashore on Tiber Island during a plague, a sanctuary was founded there in 291 B.C., and the plague ceased. Meier cites Thrämer’s count of about 410 Asclepian sanctuaries, almost all linked to Epidaurus.

Asclepius begins as a pre-Greek demon, mantic and chthonic, with the serpent and the dog. Homer knows him as a mortal physician, and after Zeus kills him with a thunderbolt for raising the dead he takes a place among the gods. He unites earth and Olympus, boy and bearded man, and he can hardly be thought of without Hygieia and the other women of his family or the hooded boy Telesphorus. Because cures were bound to their places, Meier finds in the sanctuaries “a geography of the human psyche”. Serapis, the Alexandrian healer, shared the serpent and the dog, and his companion Harpocrates holds a finger to his lips, a sign of religious silence that Meier values in psychotherapy.

The Rite in the Sanctuary

The fifth chapter, “Incubation Ritual in the Sanctuaries of Asclepius,” rebuilds the rite from Pausanias and the inscriptions. After purifications, baths and sacrifices, the sick slept in the abaton, the place not to be entered unbidden, on a couch called a kline. Meier notes the irony: “Our modern clinics are proud to derive their name from this word.” The couch came back only with Freud, he adds, and Jung’s dialectical method seats doctor and patient face to face. An inscription at Lambaesis gives the spirit of the visit: “Go in good, come out better.”

Meier thinks the patient originally had to be called by the god and was held incurable if no dream came on the first night. The god appeared as a bearded man, a boy, a serpent or a dog and touched the affected part, and the right dream brought the cure. Meier writes, “Dream interpreters did not practice in the sanctuaries.” There were no doctors there either. The cured patient recorded the dream, as analysts still ask patients to do, and paid a thank offering. The surviving stelae of Epidaurus hold at least seventy case histories, and each dream in them is introduced with edokei, “it seemed,” so that no reader would mistake it for an event.

The Cures as the Sources Report Them

Pandarus, a Thessalian with marks on his forehead, dreamed that the god bound them with a bandage, and in the morning his face was clear and the dedicated bandage bore the marks. Meier comments: “I believe the original meaning of the term “transference” lies in this idea.” Asclepius tells a patient afraid of a cold bath that he will not cure men too cowardly to be cured, and he cures poverty with dreams of hidden treasure. Some cures are dialogues. Forbidden cold water, Polemon asks, “What would you have prescribed for an ox?” Aelius Aristides, who spent twelve years in the sanctuaries, says in Meier’s translation that “it is in fact the paradox which is the highest thing in the god’s cures”, and Meier’s example is the order that sent Aristides to bathe in a river in midwinter.

The sixth chapter, “The Tholos,” reads the paintings in the round building at Epidaurus, Intoxication and Eros holding a lyre in place of his bow, as Dionysian frenzy and its Apollonian cure by music, a conjecture Meier offers as such. Modern dreams run through these chapters. One dreamer, surrounded by serpents at a forest pond, hears that “when you begin analysis, it’s a fact that the serpents start to take an interest in you.”

Trophonius and the Descent

The seventh chapter turns to the more drastic oracle of Trophonius at Lebadea. The consultant drank from the springs of Lethe and Mnemosyne, to forget his past and remember what he would see, and was then wrapped in linen bands like an infant and drawn feet first through a narrow hole into the cave. Afterward he told the priests what he had seen and only slowly recovered the power to laugh. Meier reads the descent as a birth in reverse and draws a rule from the springs: “Amnesia is an essential condition if the patient is to give himself up completely to the experience of incubation.” Plutarch’s Timarchus, who spent two nights and a day below, had in Meier’s words “a vision which has the quality of a “great dream.”” The chapter also treats the katochoi, the sick held in the sanctuaries of Serapis as prisoners of the god, and with dreams that coincided with a priest’s, which Meier links to synchronicity.

The Mystery of Healing

The eighth chapter argues that incubation was a mystery. The incubant was summoned by a dream, the decisive event came at night, and he returned reborn from a visit to the underworld. The dream was what he witnessed and the healing was the mystery itself, with the patient monos pros monon, alone with the god. The Athenians said they had initiated Asclepius into the Eleusinian mysteries. The chapter ends with the motto “Nomina mutantur, permanent numina” and Meier’s gloss that the names change while the numina remain.

From the Sanctuary to the Consulting Room

The Epilogue, “The Dream in Ancient Greece,” runs from Homer’s winged dream figure to Artemidorus, whose collection of more than three thousand dreams Meier thinks deserves more respect. With a map and Pausanias in hand, he writes, a traveler in Greece is looking at “the geography of the human soul.”

The Epicrisis, “For the Thinking Reader,” states Meier’s bridge to analysis. He takes two findings from Jung. The first reads, “The human psyche has an autochthonous spiritual function.” The second holds that no patient in the second half of life is cured without finding an approach to it. The patient must discover this element in himself, and Meier warns that “Whoever operates with a panacea fails to be an analyst”. He states the rule simply: “The illness must yield a meaning.” His example is a young catatonic patient from the early thirties, discharged within a month and still well nine years later. He admits that healing dreams are rare in modern practice, which cannot create the atmosphere of the sanctuary, and he ends on the English word for doctor: “every physician would also have to be a metaphysician.”

Beside Rohde, Dodds and Kerényi

Meier credits Erwin Rohde’s Psyche with showing how far ancient religions were cults of the psyche, and he thanks Karl Kerényi, whose Eleusis suits his chapter on the mystery. E. R. Dodds’s The Greeks and the Irrational appears in the Epilogue among the works that gathered the scanty ancient sources on dreams. Marie-Louise von Franz’s reading of Apuleius takes up the Isis mysteries that Meier uses for the summons and the katoche. James Hillman’s The Dream and the Underworld reads dreams from the realm Meier’s incubants entered at Lebadea, and Adolf Guggenbühl-Craig’s Power in the Helping Professions turns the wounded healer into a question about the helper’s own power.

Concordance

References

  • Meier, C. A. (1989). *Healing Dream and Ritual: Ancient Incubation and Modern Psychotherapy*. Daimon Verlag. ISBN 3-85630-510-6.
  • Herzog, R. (1931). Die Wunderheilungen von Epidauros. *Philologus, Supplementband 22*(3).
  • Edelstein, E. J., & Edelstein, L. (1945). *Asclepius: A Collection and Interpretation of the Testimonies* (2 vols.). Johns Hopkins Press.
  • Deubner, L. (1900). *De incubatione capita quattuor*. Teubner.
  • Rohde, E. (1898). *Psyche: Seelencult und Unsterblichkeitsglaube der Griechen* (2 vols.). J. C. B. Mohr.
  • Dodds, E. R. (1951). *The Greeks and the Irrational*. University of California Press.
  • Frazer, J. G. (Trans.). (1913). *Pausanias's Description of Greece* (6 vols.). Macmillan.