Take it into the room

What does this work illuminate for you?

Ask Sebastian about this book. He answers from the library and names his sources.

Get the letter

A Book Gathered from Two Decades of Papers

C.G. Jung and the Alchemical Imagination collects papers on alchemical themes that Stanton Marlan wrote over at least two decades, many of them in answer to invitations from training programs, analytic institutes and conferences. Marlan is a Jungian analyst who presides over the Pittsburgh Society of Jungian Analysts and teaches clinical psychology at Duquesne University. He had not imagined a book until the Brazilian analyst Leticia Capriotti urged him to gather the papers, and he arranged them to show how his ideas developed as he reread his own work. In the preface he calls each paper “a kind of alchemical experiment,” and the Introduction opens with the instruction of the Mutus Liber: “Pray. Read, Read, Read. Read Again. Work and you shall find.” Reading, for Marlan, is already an alchemical operation. “It is at once a reading and a listening.”

The fourteen chapters move in a clear order. The first surveys Jung’s discovery of alchemy and its development in the Jungian tradition, and the second describes how Marlan reads Jung. The third and fourth reprint his essays on the alchemy of soul-making and on salt. Two chapters on the metaphor of light lead to the shadow and the nigredo, then to the black sun, and from the black sun to the Philosophers’ Stone. A two-part critique of Wolfgang Giegerich follows, and the last four chapters turn to alchemical recipes and filth, the Stone as chaosmos, Hillman’s Azure Vault, and the mystical play of Divine Darkness and Divine Light.

Reading Jung Daimonically

The first chapter lists Jung’s alchemical writings, from Psychology and Alchemy, Alchemical Studies and Mysterium Coniunctionis to “The psychology of the transference,” and follows Jung’s way into the subject: his dreams of the 1920s, Richard Wilhelm’s request in 1928 for a commentary on The Secret of the Golden Flower, and the dream in which a peasant announced that they were caught in the seventeenth century. It then sets out the analysts who carried the work forward, among them Marie-Louise von Franz, Edward Edinger, James Hillman, Nathan Schwartz-Salant, Paul Kugler, Jeffrey Raff, Walter Odajnyk, Hayao Kawai, Wolfgang Giegerich and Yasuhiro Tanaka. The chapter closes modestly: “In the end, perhaps the ‘true’ meaning of alchemy will remain as elusive as the philosopher’s stone itself.”

The second chapter explains his method. Von Franz and Edinger treated Jung’s works as authoritative and saw their own books as bridges to his. Marlan values Edinger’s advice to read Jung slowly, with an open mind, and he draws back from Edinger’s idealization of Jung. In his judgment the two classical readers “at times, too easily translate alchemy into a conceptually taken-for-granted framework of Jung’s psychology.” Hillman answered by sticking to the image and moving from a psychology of alchemy to an alchemical psychology. Giegerich moved the other way, from image to the logical life of the soul. Marlan reads with all of them, and with historians such as Sonu Shamdasani and Adam McLean, while he keeps his distance from essentialist readings that make the Self a fixed center. He reads for the twilight Jung described in his essay on Paracelsus, a softer light that leaves room for dreams and the unknown. “I call such a reading a daimonic one.”

Light, Shadow and the Black Sun

The essays on light carry the book’s first large argument. In the Taoist alchemy of The Secret of the Golden Flower Marlan follows the practice of turning the light around and the birth of the spiritual embryo, and he sets both beside moments in his patients’ dreams. The next chapter turns the metaphor on Jung himself. Marlan reads Jung’s journey to Africa and his dream of the barber as a moment when Jung, identified with the light of consciousness, retreated from the descent into blackness that his search for a hidden part of himself required. He also credits Jung with a capacity for continual self-reflection, and he concludes that Jung learned that “darkness has its own logos.” The light worth keeping is the soft light of the lumen naturae.

The chapter on the shadow takes its motto from Michael Maier, “The Sun and its shadow complete the work,” and the chapter on the black sun follows that darkness further. Marlan warns that a developmental reading, from black to white, can become a defense against the radical blackness of the nigredo, and he slows down to look at the black sun as mortification, putrefaction and death, with an analytic candidate’s dream of a woman being flayed as his clinical example. He describes Sol niger as an archetypal image of the non-self with two poles. At one pole it leans toward literal annihilation, and at the other annihilation is joined to the void, to Eros and to self-forgetting. The second part of the chapter reprints the epilogue to The Black Sun, where Marlan imagines the Self under erasure. “Such a Self is always a non-Self also.”

From the Black Sun to the Stone

The ninth chapter is the hinge of the collection. Marlan pictures an alchemical stove, with Jung in an alembic on a back burner and Hillman and Giegerich boiling in front, while he prepares his own concoction from their vapors. Hillman’s Stone is sensual, soft, waxy and wounded. Giegerich’s moves toward solve, the freeing of Mercurius through sublation and the dialectics of the negative. Marlan calls such contrasts caricatures and finds real overlap, since both men stress ideas, both go beyond the literal, and both speak of some version of the death of the ego. His own conclusion keeps the darkness inside the goal: “The Philosophers’ Stone requires a relationship with the ongoing deconstructive principle of the black sun.” The Introduction puts the point in one line: “There is no illumination without darkness, no wholeness without limit.”

Against the Logical Life of the Soul

The two papers on Giegerich make the book’s sharpest argument. In the first, Marlan gives a deconstructive reading of the idea of psychology proper in What Is Soul? and contends that Giegerich “leans too far in the direction of overcoming and going beyond” the human person. He asks whether a psychology that leaves the empirical person behind absolutizes its cut until the cut becomes cutting. The second paper answers Giegerich’s dispute with Marlan’s earlier idea of an unassimilable remnant. Marlan sides with Sean McGrath’s reading of Schelling and names the remnant with an alchemical term, the caput mortuum, the dross left at the bottom of the flask after distillation and also a pigment once made from ground mummies. He imagines Jung, Hillman and Giegerich as partners in an unending conversation, and he states his own position plainly: “Rather, psychology for me is a darker art, mongrel, a mix dismissed by Giegerich.” Throughout the book he holds that thought and image each give rise to the other, which he figures with the alchemical motto solve et coagula.

Filth, Chaosmos and the Azure Vault

The last four chapters widen the frame. One begins from the old dictum “it is found in filth” and shows how spiritually minded alchemists rejected the vile ingredients of the recipes while Jung took them back. A patient’s active imagination supplies the case: a volcano goddess rises from blackened ground, a mirrored stone becomes a glowing egg, and a tree of light grows from the ash. Another chapter reads Jung’s essay on Joyce’s Ulysses and takes Joyce’s word chaosmos as one more name for the Stone, a linking of chaos and cosmos that Jung “intended but didn’t always achieve.” The chapter on Hillman’s Azure Vault defends him against his own charge of being stuck in the image, and the last chapter follows the via negativa through Jung, Hillman, Lacan, Pseudo-Dionysius and Henri Corbin. By then the stove has changed: “Jung’s ideas are back up-front and I find myself returning to consider his work again and again.”

Beside The Black Sun

The Black Sun (2005) was a study of a single image. This collection shows where that study came from and where it led. The unpublished paper on the non-self that preceded it and the epilogue that closed it stand at the middle of this book, and the chapters after them carry the black sun into the Philosophers’ Stone, the caput mortuum and chaosmos. Readers who know The Black Sun will find its darkness turned toward the goal of the work. The book should be kept apart from Jeffrey Raff’s earlier Jung and the Alchemical Imagination, which shares most of its title; Marlan’s survey counts Raff among the analysts who carried Jung’s alchemy forward. Set beside Edinger’s Anatomy of the Psyche, Hillman’s Alchemical Psychology and Giegerich’s The Soul’s Logical Life, it reads as a long conversation among Jung’s heirs, written by an analyst whose own analysts and teachers were Edinger and Hillman and who has argued with Giegerich for more than a decade.

Concordance

References

  • Marlan, S. (2021). *C.G. Jung and the Alchemical Imagination: Passages into the Mysteries of Psyche and Soul*. Routledge. ISBN 978-0-367-40527-4.
  • Marlan, S. (2005). *The Black Sun: The Alchemy and Art of Darkness*. Texas A&M University Press.
  • Jung, C. G. (1968). *Psychology and Alchemy* (R. F. C. Hull, Trans.; Collected Works, Vol. 12). Princeton University Press.
  • Jung, C. G. (1970). *Mysterium Coniunctionis* (R. F. C. Hull, Trans.; Collected Works, Vol. 14). Princeton University Press.
  • Edinger, E. F. (1985). *Anatomy of the Psyche: Alchemical Symbolism in Psychotherapy*. Open Court.
  • Hillman, J. (2010). *Alchemical Psychology* (Uniform Edition of the Writings of James Hillman, Vol. 5). Spring Publications.
  • Giegerich, W. (1998). *The Soul's Logical Life: Towards a Rigorous Notion of Psychology*. Peter Lang.
  • Giegerich, W. (2012). *What Is Soul?* Spring Journal Books.