An Anthology from a Conference on Alchemy and Seduction
Fire in the Stone: The Alchemy of Desire is an anthology of eight essays by Jungian analysts and psychologists, edited and introduced by Stanton Marlan and published by Chiron in 1997. The preface explains that it grew out of a fall conference of the Inter-Regional Society of Jungian Analysts on the theme “Alchemy and Seduction” and that Patricia Berry, Donald Kalsched, Lionel Corbett and Ronald Schenk gave their papers for publication. Essays by Marlan, Paul Kugler, James Hillman and Scott Churchill were added as the book took shape.
The introduction states the premise plainly: “For the most part, this book is inspired by the continuing vitality of the alchemical metaphor.” Marlan offers the alchemy of desire as an imagistic way of speaking about a field of relations and processes basic to Jung’s view of the dynamic psyche, and he grants that alchemy is not the explicit theme of every essay, though a majority are deeply influenced by it. He introduces each chapter and names the issues they reach, from childhood seduction and false memory syndrome to racism, feminism and mutuality between the sexes. His hope is that readers will discover “Jungian analysis as a broad and vital discipline, undergoing clarification, critique, and continuing revision.”
Marlan’s Stones
Marlan’s own chapter, “Fire in the Stone: An Inquiry into the Alchemy of Soul-making,” starts from his childhood pleasure in collecting stones. “This reflection on what the soul wants begins and ends with stones, and in an elementary sensate engagement with matter.” The guiding question comes from Hillman’s Healing Fiction and his essay “Concerning the Stone: Alchemical Images of the Goal”: what does the soul want? Holding that subtler readings of Jung avoid both rigid essentialism and relativism, Marlan draws on Hillman, Derrida and Heidegger to describe a field where the desire of the ego meets the desires of the shadow, anima, animus and other voices of the psyche, and he calls this meeting the alchemy of desire. Following Hillman on the alchemical rotatio, he takes telos back to its root sense of circling.
The clinical vignettes follow an ape and a stone. A law-abiding businessman dreamed of a King Kong figure who crushes buildings and turns out to have come to help. The last dream belongs to a young man from a fundamentalist family, whose dream woman is closed to him by a large ruby, his own birthstone. He said of it: “A ruby comes out of the earth, and when it does, it’s nothing special.” Marlan reads the red stone as an image of the alchemical goal, a reddening in which matter is crowned and the patient comes to feel an elevated sense of dignity. Images like the monkey and the stone, he concludes, “are best read with a non-essentialist eye.”
Hillman’s Black
Hillman’s “The Seduction of Black” takes the alchemical nigredo as its subject. He starts from a survey reporting that all languages have terms for black and white. In alchemy, he notes, the root khem names Egypt as the “black land,” and each color term describes the stage of the work, the condition of the material and the state of the worker together. A worker who becomes exhausted, stuck, depressed and confused is in a nigredo phase, which Hillman counts as an accomplished stage of the work. “Black breaks the paradigm; it dissolves whatever we rely upon as real and dear.” He suggests that Northern European and American racism may have begun in the moralization of color terms, and he states that “Negro is not nigredo” in order to keep human epithets apart from cosmic forces. Its last section is a warning: “We fear what we most desire and desire what we most fear.” Black can make itself “blacker than black,” a literal state beyond the touch of Mercurius duplex, and that literalism is why clinicians fear that depression will lead to literal suicide.
Seduction and the Child
Kugler’s “Childhood Seduction: Material and Immaterial Facts” starts from a debate between therapists who treat images of abuse as dissociated memories of early events and those who treat them as products of False Memory Syndrome. “No certitude exists in the profession as to what the patient’s psychic image of childhood seduction refers.” Kugler prints the relevant section of Freud’s letter to Fliess of 21 September 1897, argues that Freud expanded his aetiology to include fantasy, and sets beside it Jung’s idea of the imago. His central claim concerns the therapist, whose theory of neurosis carries an ontological commitment, a working definition of reality, that decides much of what will be experienced as real in the clinical encounter.
Berry’s “Reductionism / Finalism and the Child” turns the question on Jungian habits. In her account, Jungian theory favors the finalistic view and leads its practitioners to neglect causal thinking, a problem most acute with victims of childhood abuse. She asks what the collective image of the child as victim is pointing toward, and suggests that identification with the victim may move the psyche into an emotional place from which transformation can occur. Reduction then becomes an alchemical move toward the prima materia. Of her own return to her childhood she writes: “I have made myself prima materia.” She closes by turning Jungian shadow work on itself: “What we really need is an awareness of the shadow of shadow awareness.”
Kalsched’s Underworld Mercurius
Kalsched writes about patients whose resistance to change feels like an instinct for self-preservation. In those who suffered early trauma he finds archetypal defenses that he calls a self-care system, and he names its energy Hermes-Mercurius in what Jung calls his underworld form. His case is Mary, an ex-nun and pediatric nurse. Right after a session in which she asked whether she might call him during his vacation, she binged on a chocolate cake and a quart of ice cream, then dreamed of a doctor who lures her into a hospital of zombies. Drawing on Winnicott, Kohut, Edinger’s “Lesser Coniunctio” and Fairbairn’s Internal Saboteur, Kalsched describes a Mercurius who splits experience in order to keep the personality alive. “He protects by destroying.” Unchecked, he stops the work: “Under his supervision, all individuation comes to a halt.” Engaged in the transference, the same figure can turn his other face and become, in the alchemists’ phrase that Jung quotes, a “life-giving power like a glue” that holds the world together.
Glue, Extraction and Male Desire
Corbett takes up that glue in “Seduction, Psychotherapy, and the Alchemical Glutinum Mundi,” arguing that people often seek the cohesion of the self through seduction and through therapy. “I believe that one of the unconscious reasons people seek therapy is to find this glue, this mysterious bonding agent which will hold us together when we feel tenuous and fragile.” He calls the glue a secretion of the Self, ties it to Kohut’s selfobject needs, reads the erotic transference through the pictures of the Rosarium Philosophorum, and holds that the union must be felt psychologically while the incest taboo forbids its physical enactment. He ends with Eugene O’Neill’s line, which Kohut also quoted: “The grace of God is glue.”
Schenk’s “Mining/Fishing/Analysis: Seduction as Alchemical Extractio” begins with his own entry into a classical Freudian analysis on the couch. “It seems that we can never get away from the business of seduction in analysis.” He traces the word to Latin roots meaning to lead away and retells Hillman’s alchemical tale of tin drawn out of the earth by a young girl. The operation behind seduction is extractio, and Schenk puts it plainly: “Extraction brings forth essence.” He proposes a reciprocal flow of attraction in place of the language of projection and argues that mutual seduction, imagined as a universal dynamic, would change our idea of individuation and the self.
Churchill’s “The Alchemy of Male Desire: Femininity as Totem and Taboo” answers feminist writers who see male desire as excluding the woman as subject. Bringing Jung’s anima into dialogue with Merleau-Ponty, he argues that a man can identify with his partner and take up her role with pleasure, and that this identification can serve male individuation. He closes with an appeal to both sexes. “What is generally needed, I think, is a better sense of empathy for each other’s position: a more benevolent, more generous interpretation of the other’s desires.”
Threads Across the Essays
Alchemy supplies the shared language, and the authors turn it to different problems: Marlan’s red stone, Hillman’s black, Kalsched’s two-faced Mercurius, Corbett’s glue and Schenk’s extraction. Seduction is the second thread, a danger in the consulting room and, for Schenk, a movement away from a dominating position. The third is a challenge Marlan’s introduction names, a struggle with the notion of telos in cases of significant pathology and trauma, which Berry and Kalsched press hardest. The essays also share sources: Edinger’s Anatomy of the Psyche is cited by Marlan, Hillman and Kalsched, who takes the Lesser Coniunctio from it.