Psychoanalytic therapy occupies a contested and generative position within the depth-psychology corpus, ranging from Freud's foundational insistence that making unconscious aetiological processes conscious is the curative sine qua non, through Jung's pluralist vision of individualized, phase-sensitive treatment that moves from reductive analysis toward synthetic-dialectical work, to contemporary empirical researchers who subject long-term psychoanalytic and psychodynamic therapy to rigorous meta-analytic scrutiny. The corpus reveals at least three major axes of tension. First, the question of efficacy: de Maat, Leichsenring, and Shedler marshal controlled-trial and meta-analytic evidence demonstrating that long-term psychoanalytic therapy produces durable structural personality change beyond symptom reduction, while insisting that such gains require a treatment duration and intensity (minimally fifty sessions over a year) that distinguishes them categorically from briefer modalities. Second, the question of method and individualization: Jung explicitly resisted the imposition of a single technique, arguing that Freudian transference analysis and Adlerian social reductionism each address genuine but partial truths, and that archetypal or mythological material demands a shift to synthetic, anagogic procedure. Third, the question of what therapy aims at: Freud locates the goal in psychosynthesis and ego rationality; Horney, in self-realization against neurotic pride; Winnicott and Samuels, in relational provision and regression as a vehicle of development; Hillman, in re-evaluation rather than cure. These tensions are not resolved in the corpus but productively held, making psychoanalytic therapy one of the central organizing debates of the entire tradition.
In the library
17 passages
Freud's demand that the causes be made conscious has become the leitmotiv or basic postulate of all the more recent forms of psychotherapy. Psychopathological research during the last fifty years has proved beyond all possibility of doubt that the most important aetiological processes in neurosis are essentially unconscious
Jung identifies the making-conscious of unconscious aetiology as the shared foundational postulate uniting all serious modern psychoanalytic therapies, while framing this as Freud's decisive contribution.
Jung, Carl Gustav, The Practice of Psychotherapy: Essays on the Psychology of the Transference and Other Subjects, 1954thesis
long-term psychoanalytic therapy performed better than moderate-length psychoanalytic therapy (mean = 60 sessions) in terms of structural changes of personality... even a moderate effect on personality characteristics may be more important clinically than a large effect on symptoms.
De Maat's systematic review establishes that long-term psychoanalytic therapy produces superior structural personality change compared to shorter courses, and argues this effect is clinically more significant than symptom reduction alone.
de Maat, Saskia, The Effectiveness of Long-Term Psychoanalytic Therapy: A Systematic Review of Empirical Studies, 2009thesis
Therapist adherence to the psychodynamic prototype predicted successful outcome in both psychodynamic and cognitive therapy studies, focusing on unconscious wishes, feelings, or ideas; focusing on the therapy relationship as a topic of discussion; and drawing connections between the therapy relationship and other relationships.
Shedler demonstrates that core psychoanalytic techniques — attention to the unconscious, the therapeutic relationship, and relational patterning — predict successful outcome even across different treatment modalities.
Shedler, Jonathan, The Efficacy of Psychodynamic Psychotherapy, 2010thesis
when mythological or 'archetypal' contents appear, then is the time to give up the analytical-reductive method and to treat the symbols anagogically or synthetically, which is equivalent to the dialectical procedure and the way of individuation.
Jung articulates a phase-model of psychoanalytic therapy wherein reductive analysis gives way to synthetic-dialectical work when archetypal material emerges, moving the treatment toward individuation.
Jung, Carl Gustav, The Practice of Psychotherapy: Essays on the Psychology of the Transference and Other Subjects, 1954thesis
for the properly chosen patient, psychoanalysis is effective in terms of symptom relief, character changes, and conflict resolution.
De Maat summarizes Doidge's review conclusion that psychoanalytic therapy yields multi-level outcomes — symptomatic, characterological, and intrapsychic — when appropriately indicated.
de Maat, Saskia, The Effectiveness of Long-Term Psychoanalytic Therapy: A Systematic Review of Empirical Studies, 2009thesis
The focus of analytic treatment was to be on the fantasy relationship the patient spun around the quiet reflective presence of the doctor. All the love and hate the patient had experienced in childhood with parents would be repeated in the analytic relationship, suffered all over again, and regurgitated as wish-fulfilling dreams, slips of the tongue, emotional resistance, incestuous longings and memories, and acting-out behaviors.
Stein reconstructs the classical Freudian model of psychoanalytic therapy as organized entirely around transference repetition, with cure measured by increased rationality and ego control.
Stein, Murray, Transformation Emergence of the Self (Volume 7) (Carolyn, 1998thesis
Freud put it 'simply' when stating that psychosynthesis is the ultimate goal of psychoanalysis ('So vollzieht sich bei dem analytisch Behandelten die Psychosynthese').
De Maat locates Freud's own formulation of the therapeutic telos — psychosynthesis, the integration of a cohesive adult self — as the overarching goal orienting long-term psychoanalytic work.
de Maat, Saskia, The Effectiveness of Long-Term Psychoanalytic Therapy: A Systematic Review of Empirical Studies, 2009supporting
I have stressed the need for more extensive individualization of the method of treatment and for an irrationalization of its aims—especially the latter, which would ensure the greatest possible freedom from prejudice.
Jung argues that psychoanalytic therapy must be maximally individualized and freed from doctrinaire aims, resisting both Freudian rationalism and Adlerian social normativity.
Jung, Carl Gustav, The Practice of Psychotherapy: Essays on the Psychology of the Transference and Other Subjects, 1954supporting
Less intensive treatment is referred to as a type of psychotherapy... we would then refer to 'analytical psychotherapy' to describe treatment of less than analytical intensity but with analytical methodology and goals.
Samuels maps the institutional distinction between full analysis and psychoanalytic therapy, showing that the difference is one of frequency and intensity rather than method or aspiration.
Samuels, Andrew, Jung and the Post-Jungians, 1985supporting
Psychology simply establishes the fact that we have here a sore spot of first-rate importance. As the next stage, the stage of elucidation, will make clear, it cannot be tackled directly, because it is a problem with quite particularly pointed horns.
Jung outlines the stage-structure of psychoanalytic therapy — from confession through elucidation — insisting that the unconscious dimensions of the patient's situation cannot be approached naively or directly.
Jung, Carl Gustav, The Practice of Psychotherapy: Essays on the Psychology of the Transference and Other Subjects, 1954supporting
Balint responded to patients suffering from early emotional deprivation... by abandoning verbal interpretation and by providing the patient with the opportunity to rectify a fault in his early development instead. The analyst had, therefore, to be either an 'object' or an 'environment' which the patient could use as he wished.
Samuels documents the object-relations critique within psychoanalytic therapy, where Balint's relational and environmental provision supplants interpretive technique in cases of early deprivation.
Samuels, Andrew, Jung and the Post-Jungians, 1985supporting
there is all that unhappiness in life which we have included under 'frustration in reality,' from which all the absence of love in life proceeds—namely, poverty, family strife, mistaken choice in marriage, unfavourable social conditions, and the severity of the demands by which moral convention oppresses the individual.
Freud acknowledges the external social and material limits that constrain what psychoanalytic therapy can achieve, circumscribing its therapeutic ambition within the bounds of intrapsychic rather than social transformation.
Freud, Sigmund, Introductory Lectures on Psycho-Analysis, 1917supporting
I have a responsibility both to you, the person with whom I am talking, and to you, the person who originally came to see me, the person who, without knowing it, was asking me for my help in facing the music.
Ogden illustrates the relational ethics of psychoanalytic therapy, in which the analyst must hold responsibility to multiple aspects of the patient's selfhood simultaneously, including the part that cannot yet speak for itself.
Ogden, Thomas, This Art of Psychoanalysis: Dreaming Undreamt Dreams and Interrupted Cries, 2004supporting
There is no cure of pathologizing; there is, instead, a re-evaluation. It is this pathologized eye that, like that of the artist and the psychoanalyst, prevents the phenomena of the soul from being naively understood as merely natural.
Hillman's archetypal critique repositions psychoanalytic therapy's relationship to pathology: rather than curing suffering, the psychoanalyst — like the artist — re-evaluates it as a lens through which the soul sees.
The CCDANCTR was searched by the Group's Trials Search Co-ordinator to February 2010 using a sensitive list of terms for psychodynamic psychotherapies... psychoanalytic or psychodynamic* or (*dynamic* and (brief or *psycho* or *therap*)) or 'time limited psychotherap*'
Abbass's Cochrane methodology defines the terminological field of short-term psychoanalytic and psychodynamic therapies, mapping how the evidence base is organized around precisely specified intervention categories.
Abbass, Allan A, Short-term psychodynamic psychotherapies for common mental disorders, 2014supporting
the analyst figure in the therapeutic relationship becomes all-powerful; strong, healthy and able. The patient remains nothing but a patient; passive, dependent and prone to suffer from excessive dependency.
Samuels, drawing on Guggenbuhl-Craig, identifies the wounded-healer split as a structural hazard of psychoanalytic therapy, in which the asymmetric power relationship pathologizes the patient by denying both parties their full ambivalence.
Samuels, Andrew, Jung and the Post-Jungians, 1985aside
Alexander, F. and T. French (1946). Psychoanalytic Therapy. New York: Ronald Press.
Sedgwick's citation of Alexander and French's foundational 1946 text marks psychoanalytic therapy as a distinct technical and theoretical tradition with its own classic literature, situating Jungian work within a broader psychoanalytic lineage.
Sedgwick, David, An Introduction to Jungian Psychotherapy: The Therapeutic Relationship, 2001aside