The concordance 12 witnesses
Orientation
Hermes drove the stolen cattle so their tracks told the opposite story: movement in one direction disguised as its reverse. Rafael López-Pedraza takes this image as the archetypal form of psychic movement, indirect, duplicitous, a psychological thieving between close psyches. Murray Stein, in Jung’s Map of the Soul, makes such movement the precondition of maturation itself: without progression away from infantile fixation there would be no psychic movement out of childhood; paradise would be home. He likewise separates the self’s static structure from its kinetic dimension, the movements of the self that individuation requires. Jung’s Red Book supplies the phenomenology: strong psychic movements that consciousness could not grasp announce themselves as figures, the old sage and the maiden stepping unbidden into vision. Marie-Louise von Franz reads right dancing in fairy tale as going along with the psychic movement of life, and in Psyche and Matter argues that this felt motion carries a latent quantitative side answerable to the physical energy formula. Sri Aurobindo traces the same motion on an evolutionary arc, mind slowly disengaging from the vital process it once could not observe.
would be no psychic movement out of childhood. Paradise would be home. At the same time, the human species would fail to thrive because adaptation to harsh and demanding environments could not occur.
Stein argues that psychic movement — understood as developmental progression away from infantile fixation — is the necessary condition for both individual maturation and collective cultural evolution.
, Jung’s Map of the Soul: An Introduction, 1998thesis
The preceding experiences indicated that strong psychic movements were present that consciousness could not grasp. Two figures — the old sage and the Jung maiden — step into the field of vision, unexpectedly for consciousness.
Jung identifies strong psychic movements as the subterranean force responsible for projecting archetypal figures (Logos/Eros) into consciousness when the ego cannot independently integrate the underlying dynamic.
, The Red Book: Liber Novus, 2009thesis
dance expresses the movement of life, and to dance in a right way would be to go along with this movement, with the psychic movement of life.
Von Franz equates psychic movement with the living rhythm of the psyche itself, arguing that authentic participation — symbolized by right dancing — means aligning one’s conduct with this deeper current.
, Archetypal Patterns in Fairy Tales, 1997thesis
Although progression and regression are causally grounded in the nature of the life-processes on the one hand and in environmental conditions on the other, yet, if we look at them energically, we must think of them only as a means, as tran
Jung frames progression and regression — the two fundamental modes of psychic movement — as energic means rather than ends, subordinating their causal grounding to a teleological interpretation.
, The Interpretation of Nature and the Psyche, 1955supporting
Jung’s view of the self is both structural and dynamic. In the previous chapter, I focused mostly on its structural features. But when one considers the process o
Stein distinguishes the structural from the dynamic dimension of the self, introducing the concept of ‘movements of the self’ to capture the processual, kinetic aspect that individuation requires.
, Jung’s Map of the Soul: An Introduction, 1998supporting
The image of Hermes stealing cattle and the way in which he drove them led my imagination to connect this movement with a psychological thieving… a movement in one direction which appears as a movement in the opposite direction.
López-Pedraza reads the duplicitous, reversible movement of Hermes’ cattle-driving as an archetypal image for the indirect, disguised character of psychic movement in the context of psychological theft between close psyches.
, Hermes and His Children, 1977supporting
its movements are so involved in the life movements that it cannot detach itself from them, cannot stand separate and observe them; but in man mind has become separate
Aurobindo describes the evolution of psychic movement from total immersion in life-process toward increasingly conscious self-observation, tracing the progressive disengagement of mind from its vital matrix.
, The Life Divine, 1939supporting
Could these quantities be measured the psyche would be bound to appear as having motion in space, something to which the energy formula would be applicable.
Von Franz argues that psychic movement, while qualitatively apprehended through feeling, has a latent quantitative dimension that, if measurable, would satisfy the physical energy formula — linking psychic and physical kinetics.
, Psyche and Matter, 2014supporting
death as the primordial psychic mover; even in an illness that can be taken as having been caused, specifically, by the family history (personal complexes).
López-Pedraza proposes death as the fundamental engine of psychic movement, arguing that any psychotherapy neglecting the chthonic dimension of Hades forfeits access to the deepest transformative force.
, Hermes and His Children, 1977supporting
This is the dynamic feature of the psyche. Jung’s theory of libido conceptualizes, in an abstract way, the relationships among the various parts of the psyche.
Stein situates libido as the animating force whose movements connect the various structural elements of the psyche, providing the theoretical substrate for all talk of psychic movement.
, Jung’s Map of the Soul: An Introduction, 1998supporting
A guidance, a governance begins from within which exposes every movement to the light of Truth, repels what is false, obscure, opposed to the divine realisation.
Aurobindo describes the psychic being’s governance as the capacity to illumine every movement of the nature — a usage of ‘movement’ that encompasses impulse, habit, and psychic tendency under the soul’s discerning light.
, The Life Divine, 1939aside
a supporting peace, silence, wideness, not inert but calm, not impotent but potentially omnipotent with a concentrated, stable, immobile energy in it capable of bearing all the motions of the universe.
Aurobindo invokes the paradox of immobile energy bearing all psychic motions, implying that psychic movement is ultimately grounded in a stillness that transcends it.
, The Synthesis of Yoga, 1948aside