Mourning

several component responses widely regarded as pathological were found to be common in healthy mourning. These include anger, directed at third parties, the self, and sometimes at the person lost, disbelief that the loss has occurred

Bowlby argues that responses previously pathologised—anger, disbelief, unconscious searching—are in fact normative features of healthy adult mourning, overturning the dominant clinical consensus.

Bowlby, John, A Secure Base: Clinical Applications of Attachment Theory, 1988thesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

the psychological processes engaged in mourning, both healthy and pathological, are manifold and intricately related to each other, points of controversy have been, and still are, numerous

Bowlby maps eight contested theoretical questions structuring the mourning literature, establishing that no consensus exists on the nature, motivation, emotional constituents, or pathological variants of mourning.

Bowlby, John, Loss: Sadness and Depression (Attachment and Loss, Volume III), 1980thesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

The standard model of mourning is such a concretization and, to that extent, it reduces meaningful human experience to a mechanistic process. The new psychoanalytic mourning theory stresses the view of mourning as a crisis of meaning.

Neimeyer and Hagman argue that the Freudian standard model mechanises mourning by treating it as libidinal hydraulics, and propose instead that mourning is fundamentally a disruption and reconstruction of personal meaning.

Neimeyer, Robert A, Meaning Reconstruction and the Experience of Lossthesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

The mourning responses that are commonly seen in infancy and early childhood bear many of the features which are the hallmark of pathological mourning in the adult

Bowlby contends that what clinical theory designates as pathological adult mourning is structurally identical to normative mourning in childhood, implying a developmental continuum rather than a categorical distinction.

Bowlby, John, Loss: Sadness and Depression (Attachment and Loss, Volume III), 1980thesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

The standard model, following Freud, limits the consideration of affect to painful grieving and despondency. This has also led to the expectation that the expression of pain and grief is indicative of successful mourning.

The constructivist critique holds that the Freudian standard model arbitrarily privileges negative affect, treating humour or joy during bereavement as resistance rather than legitimate mourning responses.

Neimeyer, Robert A, Meaning Reconstruction and the Experience of Lossthesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

these emotions and wishes are but the subjective counterparts of a mourner’s urge to act—to call for and to search for the lost person—and that not infrequently he engages in those very acts, fragmented and incomplete though they be

Bowlby insists that the affective phenomenology of mourning—yearning, pining, helplessness—must be understood as the subjective register of a behavioural drive to recover the lost person, a dimension the psychoanalytic tradition had systematically neglected.

Bowlby, John, Loss: Sadness and Depression (Attachment and Loss, Volume III), 1980thesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

anger is seen as an intelligible constituent of the urgent though fruitless effort a bereaved person is making to restore the bond that has been severed. So long as anger continues, it seems, loss is not being accepted as permanent

Bowlby reads anger in mourning not as pathological but as the affective trace of the biological drive to restore severed attachment bonds, persisting precisely because hope of reunion has not yet been relinquished.

Bowlby, John, Loss: Sadness and Depression (Attachment and Loss, Volume III), 1980supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

mourning as a course that takes time until restoration of function can take place. How much functional impairment occurs is a matter of degree

Worden, following Engel, frames mourning as a temporally extended adaptive process in which the degree of functional impairment is variable and individual rather than uniform, favouring the language of adaptation over recovery.

J William Worden, ABPP, Grief Counseling and Grief Therapy A Handbook for the, 2018thesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Bowlby (1980), whose work and interest overlap with those of Parkes, reinforced the idea of phases and posits that the mourner must pass through a similar series of phases before mourning is finally resolved.

Worden documents the convergence between Parkes’s and Bowlby’s phase models of mourning, while noting that phases are non-linear and overlapping rather than strictly sequential.

J William Worden, ABPP, Grief Counseling and Grief Therapy A Handbook for the, 2018supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Mourning behavior is multidetermined, and the clinician and researcher would do well to keep this constantly in mind.

Worden argues against reductive single-variable accounts of mourning, emphasising that attachment style, meaning-making, coping capacity, and social support all co-determine the mourning trajectory.

J William Worden, ABPP, Grief Counseling and Grief Therapy A Handbook for the, 2018supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

In determining the course of mourning the most influential of these variables seems likely to be the personality of the bereaved, especially the way his attachment behaviour is organized and the modes of response he adopts to stressful situations.

Bowlby identifies the organisation of attachment behaviour as the single most powerful predictor of mourning outcome, integrating psychoanalytic vulnerability theory with attachment theory.

Bowlby, John, Loss: Sadness and Depression (Attachment and Loss, Volume III), 1980supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

A brief phase of numbing we now know to be very common following a bereavement; but we do not expect it to last more than a few days or perhaps a week. When it lasts for longer there is reason for unease

Bowlby uses prospective empirical data to distinguish normal initial numbing from its chronic form, which he reads as a sign of disordered mourning involving delayed or incomplete processing of loss.

Bowlby, John, Loss: Sadness and Depression (Attachment and Loss, Volume III), 1980supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

defensive processes are a regular constituent of mourning at every age and that what characterizes pathology is not their occurrence but the forms they take and especially the degree to which they are reversible

Bowlby reframes the psychoanalytic concept of defence in mourning: defences are universal in grief, and it is their specific form and reversibility—not their mere presence—that distinguishes healthy from pathological mourning.

Bowlby, John, Loss: Sadness and Depression (Attachment and Loss, Volume III), 1980supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Failure to recognize that a continuing sense of the dead person’s presence, either as a constant companion or in some specific and appropriate location, is a common feature of healthy mourning has led to much confused theorizing.

Bowlby rehabilitates the sense of the dead person’s continuing presence as a normative feature of healthy mourning, arguing that its pathologisation has produced theoretical confusion about identification and internalisation.

Bowlby, John, Loss: Sadness and Depression (Attachment and Loss, Volume III), 1980supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Bowlby thus conceptualised the grief reaction as a special case of separation anxiety, and the bereavement response as the consequence of irreversible separation.

Bowlby’s metapsychological position is stated explicitly: grief is not a sui generis phenomenon but a species of separation anxiety, with bereavement representing the extreme case of irreversible separation.

Bowlby, John, John Bowlby and Attachment Theory (Makers of Modern, 2014supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Most people are able to cope with these reactions and address the four tasks of mourning on their own, thereby making some kind of an adaptation to the loss.

Worden’s task model posits that uncomplicated mourning is the norm, with counselling indicated when distress levels signal elevated risk of poor bereavement outcome.

J William Worden, ABPP, Grief Counseling and Grief Therapy A Handbook for the, 2018supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

It is necessary to acknowledge and work through this pain or it can manifest itself through physical symptoms or some form of aberrant behavior.

Worden affirms the clinical necessity of processing grief pain, warning that unmourned loss converts into somatic or behavioural pathology—a view continuous with classical psychoanalytic formulations.

J William Worden, ABPP, Grief Counseling and Grief Therapy A Handbook for the, 2018supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

disordered mourning is more likely to follow the loss of someone with whom there has been, until the loss, a close relationship, in which lives are deeply intertwined, than of someone with whom the relationship has been less close

Bowlby provides empirical grounding for the clinical intuition that relational closeness and interdependence are risk factors for complicated mourning, situating this within attachment theory.

Bowlby, John, Loss: Sadness and Depression (Attachment and Loss, Volume III), 1980supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Tossing everything that belonged to the deceased right after the death can also be a clue to disordered mourning.

Worden enumerates clinical indicators of complicated mourning, noting that both preservation of and precipitate disposal of the deceased’s belongings may signal unresolved grief.

J William Worden, ABPP, Grief Counseling and Grief Therapy A Handbook for the, 2018supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

many of the items found in Criterion B such as numbness, detachment from others, and difficulty accepting the death are common experiences of normal mourners and pass with time without any special intervention

Worden engages the diagnostic controversy over complicated grief, arguing that the proposed criteria over-pathologise normative mourning responses that resolve without clinical intervention.

J William Worden, ABPP, Grief Counseling and Grief Therapy A Handbook for the, 2018supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Analysts continued to emphasize decathexis over continuity, while… Regarding the affective component of mourning

Neimeyer traces how the mainstream psychoanalytic tradition privileged libidinal withdrawal over identification and continuity with the lost object, a theoretical imbalance that the constructivist school seeks to correct.

Neimeyer, Robert A, Meaning Reconstruction and the Experience of Losssupporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

During the first week the year’s dead are remembered one by one and the bereaved are seized by renewed grieving. At the first sound of the funeral lament with which the ceremony begins, all the bereaved women stop in their tracks, suffused with sorrow.

Bowlby draws on ethnographic data from the Kota to demonstrate that structured ritual creates a socially sanctioned context for renewed acute mourning, supporting the universality of grief responses across cultures.

Bowlby, John, Loss: Sadness and Depression (Attachment and Loss, Volume III), 1980supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

final ceremonies help the living take on a new representation of the dead. To put it another way, final ceremonies symbolize a transformation of the dead, from physical beings to spiritual beings whose essence has been incorporated into the inner experience of the survivors.

Pargament argues that religious funerary ritual performs a psychological function in mourning by facilitating the transformation of the deceased from external object to internal representation within the bereaved.

Pargament, Kenneth I, The psychology of religion and coping theory, research,, 2001supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Shiva facilitates mourning by—one reminiscent of the analytic holding environment. In Shiva the caller, like the analyst, brackets her subjectivity in order to provide a large emotional space for the mourner.

Neimeyer draws an analogy between the Jewish shiva ritual and the psychoanalytic holding environment, suggesting that cultural mourning practices and clinical technique share a common facilitative structure.

Neimeyer, Robert A, Meaning Reconstruction and the Experience of Losssupporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

in most societies it is taken for granted that a bereaved person will be personally shocked and socially disoriented. Furthermore, there are certain specific types of response and belief, that, even if not universal, are very nearly so.

Bowlby marshals anthropological evidence for the near-universality of specific grief responses across cultures, reinforcing the claim that mourning has a biological substrate rather than being purely culturally constructed.

Bowlby, John, Loss: Sadness and Depression (Attachment and Loss, Volume III), 1980supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

what occurs during childhood mourning is no different in principle to what occurs during the mourning of adults. Furthermore, as we see in Chapter 21, the part played by identification in the disordered mourning of children seems also to be no different in principle

Bowlby argues for structural continuity between childhood and adult mourning, including in their pathological variants, challenging the earlier psychoanalytic position that children cannot truly mourn.

Bowlby, John, Loss: Sadness and Depression (Attachment and Loss, Volume III), 1980supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Grieving is a social phenomenon, and the need to grieve with others can be important. The degree of perceived emotional and social support from others, both inside and outside the family, is significant in the mourning process.

Worden emphasises the social embeddedness of mourning, identifying perceived social support as a key mediator of mourning outcome and challenging individualist models of grief.

J William Worden, ABPP, Grief Counseling and Grief Therapy A Handbook for the, 2018supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Soon the chief brought up the topic of his dead son, Noakena, and said, rather bitterly, ‘He abandoned me and went off to sea.’

Bowlby presents a detailed ethnographic case of a Tikopian chief’s mourning to illustrate how anger, bitterness, and dreaming of the deceased are cross-culturally consistent features of grief following sudden loss.

Bowlby, John, Loss: Sadness and Depression (Attachment and Loss, Volume III), 1980aside

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Over time, new beliefs may be adopted or old ones reasserted or modified to reflect the fragility of life and the limits of control.

Worden notes that mourning often precipitates revision of assumptive world beliefs, with bereaved persons negotiating between shattered and restored frameworks of meaning over the course of grief.

J William Worden, ABPP, Grief Counseling and Grief Therapy A Handbook for the, 2018aside

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

The mourners themselves are expected to accept death stoically and return to work wi

Pargament observes that modern Western funeral practices truncate the mourning process by imposing rapid stoic recovery, contrasting with traditional rituals that provided extended social containers for grief.

Pargament, Kenneth I, The psychology of religion and coping theory, research,, 2001aside

Dig deeper with Sebastian →