The concept of identity structure occupies a pivotal, though variously theorized, position across the depth-psychological corpus. Most rigorously developed by John Welwood within a Buddhist-psychotherapeutic synthesis, the term designates the organized configuration of beliefs, compensatory self-images, and subconscious deficiency feelings through which the ego constitutes and maintains its sense of selfhood. Welwood insists the structure is dual: a conscious, positive self-presentation that masks an underlying subconscious identity of inadequacy, the two locked in a compensatory dynamic he calls the 'identity project.' James Hall, working from Jungian premises, introduces a historicizing inflection, treating identity structures as fluid configurations of complexes whose transformation can be tracked through sequential dream series, with both ego and Self influencing which complexes anchor a dominant identity at any given moment. Murray Stein situates this problematic within the ego-persona relation, showing how identification with social roles can eclipse authentic inner identity, while Ricoeur approaches structural selfhood through the dialectic of sameness and selfhood, arguing that narrative emplotment provides the most adequate account of personal identity's persistence through time. Daniel Siegel introduces a neurobiological and relational dimension, framing identity as an inner-and-inter construction requiring integration of differentiated elements. The field-wide tension is between identity structure as defensively rigid formation in need of dissolution (Welwood) and as a necessary, developmentally evolving organization that grounds coherent selfhood (Hall, Stein, Siegel).
In the library
18 passages
The identity structure is generally comprised of two halves: the conscious identity—a positive image of self that we actively try to promote in order to compensate for an underlying subconscious identity—a sense of deficiency that we try to cover up
Welwood's canonical definition posits identity structure as a dual formation—compensatory conscious self-image over a concealed subconscious sense of deficiency—driving the perpetual 'identity project.'
Welwood, John, Toward a Psychology of Awakening Buddhism, Psychotherapy,, 2000thesis
The relational context of psychotherapy can often provide a direct, focused, and precise method of working through the subconscious dynamics that keep this whole identity structure intact.
Welwood argues that the compensatory/deficient ego structure comprising identity cannot be dissolved through spiritual practice alone but requires psychotherapeutic engagement with its embedded interpersonal dynamics.
Welwood, John, Toward a Psychology of Awakening Buddhism, Psychotherapy,, 2000thesis
When we put an identity structure under the microscope of awareness, we find that it is made of a number of little beliefs linked together. Each of those beliefs needs to be exposed.
Welwood reveals that identity structures are constituted by interlocking belief-systems, and that therapeutic and contemplative work must disassemble each constituent belief in order to dissolve the whole structure.
Welwood, John, Toward a Psychology of Awakening Buddhism, Psychotherapy,, 2000thesis
A sense of the changing process of identity structures is quite helpful in clinical uses of dreams. Both the ego and the Self, therefore, influence the structure of the complexes upon which the ego relies for its own sense of identity.
Hall establishes that identity structures are clinically observable through dream series as shifting complex-configurations, co-determined by both ego activity and the Self's transformative influence.
Hall, James A., Jungian Dream Interpretation: A Handbook of Theory and Practice, 1983thesis
This fear of nonexistence gives rise to our ongoing identity project—the attempt to make ourselves into something solid, substantial, and real.
Welwood grounds the formation of identity structures developmentally in the universal existential threat of nonexistence, which propels the ego's compensatory project of self-solidification.
Welwood, John, Toward a Psychology of Awakening Buddhism, Psychotherapy,, 2000supporting
If identity is both inner and inter, we can see that the question of integrating identity becomes a pressing focus of our attention. Without integration, we can excessively differentiate without linkage, perhaps feeling isolated as a solo-self
Siegel reconceives identity structure as simultaneously intrapsychic and relational, arguing that health requires integration of differentiated identity elements rather than either isolated selfhood or premature merger.
Siegel, Daniel J., The Developing Mind: How Relationships and the Brain Interact to Shape Who We Are, 2020supporting
The identity of the character is comprehensible through the transfer to the character of the operation of emplotment, first applied to the action recounted; characters, we will say, are themselves plots.
Ricoeur argues that personal identity achieves structural coherence through narrative emplotment, wherein character identity is not a fixed substance but a narrative construction integrating action over time.
it is within the framework of narrative theory that the concrete dialectic of selfhood and sameness—and not simply the nominal distinction between the two terms employed up until now—attains its fullest development.
Ricoeur contends that the philosophical problem of identity structure—how sameness and selfhood cohere across time—receives its most adequate resolution in narrative theory rather than in substantialist or psychological accounts.
our self-structure is under the sway of a more primitive capacity—identification. Because we l[ack the reflective distance to see it as such]
Welwood traces the formation of identity structures to prereflective identification in childhood, prior to the development of self-reflective capacity, establishing the developmental precondition for later therapeutic work.
Welwood, John, Toward a Psychology of Awakening Buddhism, Psychotherapy,, 2000supporting
the ego tends to identify with the roles it plays in life… there is always more to the ego than persona identification. The persona will at most form a close wrapping around the side of the ego that faces out into the social world.
Stein, following Jung, distinguishes between a superficial identity structure constituted by persona-role identification and the ego's deeper archetypal core, cautioning against conflating the two.
Stein, Murray, Jung's Map of the Soul: An Introduction, 1998supporting
a 'fog' would arise in his mind… This fog arose only in moments when he was on the verge of getting in touch with something that might allow him to move beyond his cripple identity.
Welwood's case material illustrates how identity structures generate defensive psychological operations that obstruct therapeutic access to the very material needed to dissolve them.
Welwood, John, Toward a Psychology of Awakening Buddhism, Psychotherapy,, 2000supporting
The four archetypes of boyhood, each with a triangular structure, can be put together to form a pyramid that depicts the structure of the boy's emerging identity, his immature masculine Self.
Moore frames identity structure in archetypal-developmental terms, showing that the masculine self is organized across life stages by successive archetypal configurations that form an evolving pyramidal structure.
Moore, Robert, King Warrior Magician Lover: Rediscovering the Archetypes of the Mature Masculine, 1990supporting
In a dissociative identity disorder the ego has taken such a battering that it cannot hold its own against the unconscious; then the psyche shifts automatically to an alternative reality.
Hollis treats identity structure as a function of ego integrity, with dissociative identity disorder representing its pathological collapse under the pressure of overwhelming unconscious material.
Hollis, James, Swamplands of the Soul: New Life in Dismal Places, 1996supporting
The crucial point to remember is that the ego-image itself may alter depending upon which complex (or combination of complexes) the ego uses for a dominant identity.
Hall demonstrates the dynamic, complex-dependent nature of ego-identity, showing that the dominant identity structure at any moment is contingent on which complexes are constellated around the ego.
Hall, James A., Jungian Dream Interpretation: A Handbook of Theory and Practice, 1983supporting
Sameness is a concept of relation and a relation of relations. First comes numerical identity… To this first component of the notion of identity corresponds the notion of identification, understood in the sense of the reidentification of the same
Ricoeur analytically decomposes the concept of identity into numerical sameness, qualitative resemblance, and temporal continuity, providing the philosophical scaffolding for distinguishing stable identity structure from mere resemblance.
The retentional-protentional structure of consciousness… is constitutive of self-identity within the changing flow of consciousness; it generates the basic sense of auto-affection or ipseity.
Gallagher locates the most primordial stratum of identity structure in the temporal micro-structure of consciousness itself—the retentional-protentional flow that generates ipseity prior to any reflective self-concept.
Gallagher, Shaun, How the Body Shapes the Mind, 2005aside
Identification then leads to the formation of a secondary character, the individual identifying with his best developed function to such an extent that he alienates himself very largely or even entirely from his original character
Jung identifies function-identification as a mechanism by which a secondary, partial identity structure supplants authentic individuality, framing this as a necessary but ultimately transcendable transitional stage.
liminality: deconstruction, integrati[on]… the three fundamental processes that govern the attainment of transformation and transgression into a new phase of life
Janusz and Walkiewicz invoke rites-of-passage theory to describe how identity structures are deconstructed and reconstituted at liminal thresholds in the life course.
Janusz, Bernadetta; Walkiewicz, Maciej, The Rites of Passage Framework as a Matrix of Transgression Processes in the Life Course, 2018aside