The depth-psychology corpus approaches drunkenness through at least four distinct registers, each illuminating a different face of the same phenomenon. The Gnostic-hermeneutic register, represented most forcefully by Hans Jonas, reads drunkenness as a cosmological metaphor: the 'wine of ignorance' proffered by the powers of the world actively induces the soul's oblivion of its own alien origin, so that drunkenness is not mere incapacity but a positively maintained counter-condition to gnosis. A second, mythological register—developed by Otto and Hillman—locates drunkenness within the Dionysian economy, where intoxication discloses both divine revelry and destructive frenzy, the two faces of a god who is simultaneously liberator and annihilator. William James introduces a third, phenomenological register, tracing the 'sway of alcohol' as a genuine, if pathological, gateway to mystical consciousness, a claim that resonates with Jung's youthful ecstasy at the distillery and his subsequent theorization of the spirit-longing latent in addiction. The biblical-moral register, largely represented by Shaw, reframes drunkenness as sin rather than disease, insisting that naming it correctly restores hope by making it treatable through repentance. The tension between the ontological-symbolic readings (Jonas, Otto, Hillman, James) and the clinical-moral readings (Shaw, Abraham, Schoen) constitutes the central theoretical fault-line in the corpus's treatment of this term.
In the library
12 passages
The 'drunkenness' of the world is a phenomenon peculiarly characteristic of the spiritual aspect of what the Gnostics understood by the term 'world.' It is induced by the 'wine of ignorance'… ignorance is not a neutral state, the mere absence of knowledge, but is itself a positive counter-condition to that of knowledge, actively induced and maintained to prevent it.
Jonas argues that Gnostic drunkenness is a cosmological weapon wielded by worldly powers to suppress the soul's awareness of its own alienation, making intoxication a metaphysical rather than merely ethical problem.
Hans Jonas, The Gnostic Religion: The Message of the Alien God and the Beginnings of Christianity, 1958thesis
There was no longer any inside or outside, no longer an 'I' and the 'others,' No. 1 and No. 2 were no more… I was shamefully, gloriously, triumphantly drunk.
McCabe presents Jung's adolescent drunkenness as a premonitory dissolution of ego-boundaries that prefigures his later theorization of the spiritual craving underlying alcoholic compulsion.
McCabe, Ian, Carl Jung and Alcoholics Anonymous: The Twelve Steps as a Spiritual Journey of Individuation, 2015thesis
Whether someone drinks, snorts, shoots, inhales, smokes, dissolves, or imbibes a drug, the effects of the substance will be 'drunkenness' which is what God has called the problem all along.
Shaw proposes that 'drunkenness' is the Bible's comprehensive term for all substance-induced alteration of consciousness, making it a moral-theological category rather than a medical one.
Shaw, Mark E., The Heart of Addiction: A Biblical Perspective, 2008thesis
Wine has a vernacular relationship with blue drunkenness, blue noses, and blue laws of prohibition, and at the other end of the spectrum wine is the carrier of divine drunkenness in the mystical states of Rumi and Kabīr.
Hillman situates drunkenness on a spectrum running from pathological degradation to Dionysian-mystical revelation, insisting that the same symbol holds both poles simultaneously within alchemical psychology.
The next step into mystical states carries us into a realm that public opinion and ethical philosophy have long since branded as pathological… I refer to the consciousness produced by intoxicants and anæsthetics, especially by alcohol.
James positions alcohol-induced intoxication as a contested but genuine threshold to mystical consciousness, challenging the purely moralistic dismissal of drunkenness.
James, William, The Varieties of Religious Experience Amazon, 1902thesis
Is the word 'drunkard' too harsh and mean-spirited to describe someone who continually gives themselves over to the sin of drunkenness? The Lord Jesus Himself uses it to describe this person. It is a true description and name for the problem and it gives the Christian hope.
Shaw defends the retention of the biblical lexicon of drunkenness as therapeutically necessary, arguing that accurate moral naming is the precondition for genuine hope of redemption.
Shaw, Mark E., The Heart of Addiction: A Biblical Perspective, 2008supporting
uninhibited, violent, murderous, and brutally aggressive sexual behavior that at times happens with drunkenness… Most violent crimes—assaults, murders, spouse and child abuse, and rape—are alcohol- and/or drug-related events.
Schoen connects drunkenness to the Maenadlike eruption of the archetypal shadow, linking mythological frenzy to clinical data on alcohol-related violence.
Schoen, David E., The War of the Gods in Addiction: C.G. Jung, Alcoholics Anonymous and Archetypal Evil, 2020supporting
You do not have to be a life-dominated drunkard to commit the sin of drunkenness. In fact, if you are one who sometimes gets drunk with alcohol or occasionally uses too much of a prescription drug, you may be in a worse spiritual condition than a drunkard!
Shaw extends the moral category of drunkenness to occasional excess, arguing that episodic intoxication may indicate more dangerous self-deception than chronic dependency.
Shaw, Mark E., The Heart of Addiction: A Biblical Perspective, 2008supporting
Wine even has the ability to dispel the restlessness of Fate's goddesses… Wine overcame 'even the centaurs'… With its help Midas masters Silenus, who then has to reveal hidden knowledge to him.
Otto documents the mythological power of wine-induced intoxication as a force that overcomes divine and bestial resistances alike, positioning drunkenness within a wider cosmology of Dionysian sovereignty.
Otto, Walter F, Dionysus Myth and Cult (1965), 1965supporting
It is hardly necessary to mention that many brutal crimes are perpetrated in states of alcoholic intoxication. Nevertheless, the repressed component-instincts need not necessarily be expressed in such a crude way.
Abraham reads drunkenness psychoanalytically as the disinhibition of repressed sadistic and erotic component-instincts, locating its dynamics in the economy of unconscious drive life.
Abraham, Karl, Selected Papers on Psychoanalysis, 1927supporting
A touch of drunkenness made Etienne's eyes flame. He cried, 'Yes, let's be together… for justice I would give everything, drink and women. There's only one thing that warms my heart, it's the idea that we are going to get rid of the bosses.'
Auerbach uses a moment of literary drunkenness in Zola to illustrate how naturalist fiction deploys intoxication as the catalyst that releases suppressed collective passions and political affect.
Auerbach, Erich, Mimesis: The Representation of Reality in Western Literature, 1953aside
When I was drinking, or at least toward the end of that period, I felt very much as though I were in the grip of something unspeakably evil.
This survivor narrative articulates the phenomenological experience of late-stage alcoholism as possession by an alien evil force, a description that resonates with both Gnostic and Jungian accounts of drunkenness as demonic seizure.
Addenbrooke, Mary, Survivors of Addiction: Narratives of Recovery, 2011aside