The concordance 19 witnesses
Also traced as associations
Orientation
A patient sits across from Jung and answers a single word, and in the pause before her reply, a marriage collapses into view. Jung called the procedure a “kind of pastime, a conversation between experimenter and subject,” but the data it produced overturned the assumption that a person controls what a word calls up in them. Timing his subjects’ reactions to a fixed stimulus list, he catalogued disturbances, perseverations, and what he named the attention phenomenon, an abrupt, oddly flat reply that betrays exactly the inhibition it is meant to conceal. In one case the pattern of delays and mistaken repetitions led him to a divorce-complex his patient had never spoken aloud and, confronted with it, at first denied. Perseveration showed him something further: a feeling-toned response does not end with its own utterance but leaves a trace that conditions the next answer, and the one after that, so that a single charged word can organize an entire sequence. The conclusion Jung drew was severe: consciousness plays only a minor role in association. What organizes the chain is the complex, working beneath intention, using the stimulus-word as its occasion.
The association experiment, too, is not merely a method for the reproduction of separate word-pairs but a kind of pastime, a conversation between experimenter and subject.
Jung argues that the association experiment is not a mechanical word-pairing procedure but a meaningful interpersonal exchange that reveals the subject’s entire psychological attitude toward the stimulus-situation.
, Experimental Researches, 1904thesis
From these facts it becomes evident that consciousness plays only a minor role in the process of association.
Jung draws from reaction-time data the radical conclusion that unconscious feeling-toned constellations, not conscious intention, are the true determinants of associative responses.
, Experimental Researches, 1904thesis
WORD ASSOCIATION … the associations with to write are complexes of school-memories, the connection of which is conditioned by simultaneity; the other examples concern reactive images associated with the stimulus images by co-existence.
This passage enumerates the principal classificatory categories of word association responses — simultaneity, co-existence, identity, causal relationship — establishing the taxonomic framework of Jung’s experimental programme.
, Experimental Researches, 1904thesis
A subject who interprets the stimulus-word as a question and therefore produces a series of highly potent associations suddenly, in the absence of external disturbance, reacts with a sound or some other strikingly superficial association.
Jung identifies the ‘attention phenomenon’ — an abrupt superficial reaction replacing expected associations — as the betrayal of an unconscious inhibition and the presence of a complex.
, Experimental Researches, 1904thesis
For the sake of clarity I am now going to describe the association experiments that I carried out with the patient.
In a clinical application to a long-standing hysteria case, Jung demonstrates how the association experiment serves as the diagnostic instrument for uncovering the psychic substrate of chronic symptoms.
, Experimental Researches, 1904supporting
The patient therefore had a divorce-complex, for she was very dissatisfied with her married life. When I told her this result she was very shaken and at first tried to deny it.
Jung illustrates the diagnostic power of association results to disclose a ‘divorce-complex’ that the patient herself could not consciously acknowledge, validating the experiment’s psychotherapeutic utility.
, Experimental Researches, 1904supporting
By perseveration we understand a phenomenon that consists in the fact that the preceding association conditions the next reaction.
Jung defines perseveration as the carry-over influence of one feeling-toned association upon its successor, revealing the temporal spread of complex-constellations across the experimental series.
, Experimental Researches, 1904supporting
A preceding emotionally charged association can leave a trace in the unconscious and unconsciously constellate the reaction, particularly when the preceding association had a strong feeling-tone.
Jung demonstrates that affectively charged associations leave unconscious traces that silently determine subsequent reactions, linking the associative process directly to feeling-tone and the complex.
, Experimental Researches, 1904supporting
These few examples may suffice to show that quite a number of associations are constellated by a feeling-toned complex. This state of affairs in itself is not at all abnormal, since the associations of normal people are also often so constellated.
Jung normalises complex-constellated associations, arguing that the same underlying mechanism operates in both pathological and healthy subjects, thereby bridging clinical and experimental psychology.
, Experimental Researches, 1904supporting
We know, of course, that no reaction is fortuitous, but that each one, even the most objective, is caused by definite constellations.
Jung posits a principle of universal psychic determinism: every association, however seemingly neutral, is causally governed by the subject’s unconscious constellation at the moment of response.
, Experimental Researches, 1904supporting
The stimulus-words are repeated because they influence hysterical individuals as difficult personal questions do. In principle it is the same phenomenon as the additions to the reaction.
Jung identifies repetition of the stimulus-word by hysterical subjects as a defensive manoeuvre structurally equivalent to other complex-indicators, linking associative disturbance to hysterical phenomenology.
, Experimental Researches, 1904supporting
All these data were at the time of the reaction unconscious. The complex betrayed itself at first only by the slightly unpleasant but otherwise indefinable feeling shown in 148.
Through case-by-case analysis, Jung shows how the emotional content of a complex is entirely unconscious at the moment of its associative betrayal, accessible only retrospectively through subsequent analytic reconstruction.
, Experimental Researches, 1904supporting
No schema could ever be invented that would make possible a clear-cut classification of all associations. But there is a number of co-ordinations that could without undue strain be placed under different headings.
Jung concedes the irreducible empirical fluidity of associative categories, cautioning against over-systematisation and affirming the classificatory schemas as heuristic rather than exhaustive.
, Experimental Researches, 1904supporting
association(s): categories/classification of, 74; familial patterns of, 475; free, 82, 84, 187, 188, 190–92, 478; method, 6 association experiments/tests, 48–56.
The Symbolic Life index entry documents the full range of Jung’s associations-related concerns — classification, family constellation, free association, and experimental method — within a single systematic overview.
, Collected Works Volume 18: The Symbolic Life, 1976supporting
Aschaffenburg’s schema has been tested on a great deal of material, part of it pathological, and has proved itself of value. His conditio sine qua non is not the subsequent questioning of the subjects about the reaction phenomenon.
Jung evaluates competing classificatory schemas for associations, endorsing Aschaffenburg’s system for its practical utility in psychopathological contexts where post-hoc questioning of subjects is unavailable.
, Experimental Researches, 1904supporting
association in, 547–53; complexes in, 602; dreams in, 395f; galvanometer and pneumograph experiments in, 496, 514–24.
The Experimental Researches index maps the intersection of association with dementia praecox, complexes, dreams, and galvanometric measurement, revealing the breadth of its diagnostic and theoretical applications.
, Experimental Researches, 1904supporting
Psychoanalysis and Association Experiments … Association, Dream, and Hysterical Symptom … The Psychopathological Significance of the Association Experiment.
The table of contents of Experimental Researches maps the programmatic scope of Jung’s word-association research programme, situating it within psychoanalysis, psychopathology, and dream theory.
, Experimental Researches, 1904aside
The Association Method (1910) / Reaction-Time in Association Experiments / On Disturbances in Reproduction in Association Experiments / The Significance of Association Experiments for Psychopathology / Psychoanalysis and Association Experiments.
This bibliographic listing from The Spirit in Man records the canonical sequence of Jung’s association publications, confirming the sustained institutional importance of the method across his early career.
, The Spirit in Man, Art, and Literature, 1966aside
In the association pencil/length, length is essentially contained in the concept or is co-existent, while in father/worry the concept worry adds something new and therefore causes a shifting of concept.
Jung distinguishes analytic from synthetic associative judgments through concrete examples, illustrating how ego-referential predicates introduce new conceptual content beyond the stimulus-word’s inherent meaning.
, Experimental Researches, 1904aside