What the Encyclopedia Is
The Encyclopedia of Psychology and Religion was published by Springer in 2010 under three editors in chief: David A. Leeming of the Blanton-Peale Institute, Kathryn Madden of the National Institute for the Psychotherapies, and Stanton Marlan of the Pittsburgh Center for Psychotherapy and Psychoanalysis. Its signed articles, each by a named contributor or a team of contributors, run in one alphabetical sequence, and its title page notes 15 figures and 2 tables.
The project began at Blanton-Peale. According to the preface, Kenneth Giniger suggested to Holly Johnson, then the Institute’s president, that it compile an encyclopedia of psychology and religion, and she began planning the work with her colleagues Walter Odajnyk and David Leeming. Springer, which had long worked with Blanton-Peale on the Journal of Religion and Health, became the publisher. Leeming served as managing editor, with Felice Noelle Rodriguez as associate managing editor.
The preface introduces the three editors. Leeming has taught courses in myth, religion and literature for many years, his books include the Oxford Companion to World Mythology, and he edited the Journal of Religion and Health. Madden earned her degrees in psychology and religion at Union Theological Seminary, served as dean and later president of Blanton-Peale, and edits Quadrant. Marlan is a clinical psychologist and a training and supervising analyst for the Inter Regional Society of Jungian Analysts, and he has edited the Journal of Jungian Theory and Practice. Norman Vincent Peale and the psychologist Smiley Blanton founded the Institute in 1937 as a clinic and training institute devoted to integrating religion and psychology, and the preface presents the encyclopedia as a natural outgrowth of that work.
What the Editors Say It Is For
The preface states the aim in one sentence: “Each entry is intended to create a tension of meaning between traditional religious terms and psychological interpretations.” The editors seek “new and latent deposits of meaning” that bear on self-understanding, cross-cultural interpretation and therapy, and they disclaim any single definitive reading. They also explain a feature a reader soon notices: “Occasionally, more than one article on a given subject is included to present different points of view.”
The introduction supplies the history behind that aim. The editors hold that the great religions have always been repositories of psychological truths, and that from a psychological perspective they work as therapeutic systems for life’s transitions and crises. With the rise of scientific rationalism the two fields grew estranged, and the tradition inspired by Freud, they write, “tended to view religion as an illusion, a cultural vestige of immaturity and projection.” They credit William James, C. G. Jung, Roberto Assagioli, Viktor Frankl, Erik Erikson, Gordon Allport, Erich Fromm and Abraham Maslow with challenging the secular paradigm, joined in the 1970s by the transpersonal psychologists. As a sign of change they point to the 1994 Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, which added a classification for “Religious or Spiritual Problems.” The encyclopedia, they write, grows out of “the need to reintegrate the sciences of the mind with the science of the spirit.” The preface names its intended readers: “researchers, academics, teachers, clergy, therapists, counselors, and other professionals” working where the two fields meet.
Traditions from Abraham and Isaac to Zoroastrianism
The preface promises entries from the modern world religions, Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Buddhism and Hinduism, and also from African Animism, pre-Christian Celtic and Germanic traditions, Egyptian, Greek and Gnostic religion, and Native North American and Mesoamerican movements. The entries bear this out. The first is “Abraham and Isaac” and the last is “Zoroastrianism.” Between them stand “Sufis and Sufism,” “Hasidism,” “Kabbalah,” “Tantrism,” “Vedanta,” “Taoism,” “Confucianism,” “Shinto,” “Chan Buddhism” and “Zen,” along with “Celtic Religions,” “Osiris and the Egyptian Religion,” “Eleusinian Mysteries,” “Orpheus and Orphism,” “Gnosticism,” “Wicca,” “Curanderismo,” “Peyote Religion” and “Native American Messianism.” Other entries treat single figures, from “Augustine” and “Teresa of Avila” to “Ramana Maharshi” and “Black Elk.”
The Schools of Psychology
The psychology is as varied as the religion. Freud has entries of his own in “Freud, Sigmund” and “Freud, Sigmund, and Religion,” and the later psychoanalytic schools follow in “Object Relations Theory,” “Winnicott, Donald Woods, and Religion,” “Kohut, Heinz,” “Self Psychology,” “Relational Psychoanalysis,” “Lacan, Jacques” and “Kristeva, Julia.” Analytical psychology, Marlan’s own field, has Murray Stein’s “Jung, Carl Gustav,” entries on “Archetype,” “Individuation” and “Active Imagination,” and separate entries on Jung and religion, alchemy, Gnosticism, Eastern religious traditions and phenomenology. Existential and humanistic psychology appear in “Existential Psychotherapy,” “Daseinsanalysis,” “Frankl, Viktor” and “Rogers, Carl,” and behaviorism in “Skinner, Burrhus Frederic.” There are entries on “Transpersonal Psychology” and “Wilber, Ken,” on “Liberation Psychology,” on pastoral care in “Pastoral Counseling” and “Boisen, Anton,” and on empirical research in “Religious Coping” and “Genetics of Religiosity.”
How an Entry Is Written
The entries are signed essays of varying length with their own section headings. The opening entry, “Abraham and Isaac” by Anais N. Spitzer, retells the binding of Isaac in Genesis 22 and then reads the story under four headings: “Qur’anic Significance,” “Søren Kierkegaard,” “Freudian Perspective” and “Jungian Perspective.” It closes with a “See also” list of related entries and a bibliography.
Some entries have several authors. “Forgiveness,” by Everett L. Worthington, Jr., Jennifer S. Ripley, Don E. Davis and Benjamin T. Wood, opens with a plain statement, “Every major religion endorses forgiveness as a virtue,” and then asks what the scientific study of forgiveness can add to religious teaching. A second article, “Forgiveness and the Brain” by James G. Emerson, follows it. “Black Elk” is written by Richard W. Voss with George A. Looks Twice, Black Elk’s grandson, and with Georgine Leona Looks Twice, Alex Lunderman, Jr. and Vern Ziebart. It draws on the interviews John G. Neihardt published in Black Elk Speaks and on what the family remembers. “Family members recall that he continued to pray with the pipe,” the entry reports, though some say he gave up the traditional ceremonies after he became a Catholic.
Related subjects often come in clusters. Bernard Spilka’s “God Image” separates the God image from the God concept and judges the significance of that distinction indeterminate until Piedmont and Muller’s findings are fully reported and confirmed. Annette Peterson wrote four related entries, “God Image and Therapy,” “God Image in Dreams,” “Female God Images” and “Male God Images,” and writes from the side of the clinic: “Our God images are mirrors of ourselves.”
What a Seba Reader Can Use It For
For a Seba reader the encyclopedia is a first stop for the religious vocabulary of depth psychology. Ann Casement’s “Numinosum” explains that the term is one “Jung appropriated from Rudolf Otto’s The Idea of the Holy,” and Leon Schlamm’s “Jung, Carl Gustav, and Religion” shows how Jung drew on Otto’s account of numinous experience and, unlike Otto, located its source “in the unconscious rather than beyond the psyche.” David M. Wulff’s “Psychology of Religion” maps the field itself. He defines it as “the systematic application of psychology’s methods and interpretive frameworks to the broad domain of religion,” separates it from religious psychology, from psychology and religion, and from psychology as religion, and traces it to William James, Stanley Hall and Theodore Flournoy. He also notes that the field “has been an academic stepchild from its beginnings.”
The editors’ own entries show their interests. Leeming wrote on myth and ritual, including “Monomyth,” “Trickster,” “Axis Mundi” and “Divine Child,” and his “Monomyth” follows Joseph Campbell’s hero through departure, adventure and return: “The hero does not stand for the status quo; he or she breaks new ground.” Madden wrote “Dark Mother,” “Dark Night of the Soul,” “Descent to the Underworld” and “Eros.” Marlan contributed “Hillman, James, and Alchemy,” which sets Jung’s reading of alchemy beside Hillman’s and records Hillman’s “distinction between a psychology of alchemy and an alchemical psychology.” The entry lists Hillman’s alchemical papers from “On Senex Consciousness” in 1970 to “The Azure Vault” in 2006, and readers coming from Marlan’s The Black Sun can start there.
The entries carry their sources. A reader who opens “Zen,” where Paul C. Cooper observes that “not unlike psychotherapy, Zen is interpersonal, experiential and relies on direct dialog,” can follow its citations to D. T. Suzuki, Erich Fromm and Karen Horney. The entries vary in method and voice, as the preface intends, and the work’s use is to put a religious term and its psychological readings in one place, with the bibliography a reader needs to go further.