Unconscious Participation

Unconscious Participation designates the condition in which a subject is merged with, and governed by, contents of the unconscious without registering that merger as such — a state in which the boundary between self and world, or between inner image and outer reality, dissolves below the threshold of reflective awareness. The concept draws its foundational vocabulary from Lévy-Bruhl’s participation mystique, which Jung appropriated and systematized: what the ethnologist observed in so-called primitive mentality, Jung identified as a universal psychic substrate that civilised consciousness has only partially overcome. The corpus divides on valuation. For Jung and Neumann, unconscious participation represents both the historical ground of ego-development and a persistent liability — the undifferentiated uroboric state from which individual consciousness must wrest itself, yet into which mass psychology perpetually regresses. Neumann maps the transition from group-psychic submersion toward individuated awareness as the central drama of psychic evolution. From a clinical standpoint, the dissolution of participation mystique through analysis is, in Jung’s own formulation, ‘the therapeutic effect par excellence.’ Alchemical Studies extends this insight cosmologically: when the unconscious ceases to be projected, the primordial participation with things is abolished and contemplative freedom becomes possible. Tension persists between treating unconscious participation as pathological regression and recognising its generative, compensatory function in creative and religious experience.

In the library 14 passages

it is the therapeutic effect par excellence, for which I labour with my students and patients, and it consists in the dissolution of participation mystique… no consciousness of the difference between subject and object, an unconscious identity prevails.

Jung identifies the dissolution of unconscious participation — the undifferentiated merger of subject and object inherited from primitive mentality — as the supreme goal of therapeutic work.

Jung, C. G., Collected Works Volume 3: The Psychogenesis of Mental Disease, 1907thesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

existence in the uroboros was existence in participation mystique… no ego center had as yet developed… Between the hunted animal and the will of the hunter there existed a magical, mystical rapport… this lack of differentiation was precisely what constituted the weakness and defenselessness of the ego.

Neumann situates unconscious participation as the defining condition of uroboric existence, in which the absent ego boundary renders the individual indistinguishable from group, nature, and archetype.

Neumann, Erich, The Origins and History of Consciousness (Princeton, 2019thesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

The unconscious is not projected any more, and so the primordial participation mystique with things is abolished. Consciousness is no longer preoccupied with compulsive plans but dissolves in contemplative vision.

Jung frames the cessation of unconscious projection as the alchemical-psychological moment in which participation mystique ends and a liberated, contemplative consciousness becomes possible.

Jung, Carl Gustav, Alchemical Studies, 1967thesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

the participation mystique of the group psyche… consciousness is still in abeyance, being not yet developed or only partially developed… ‘the social, like the hypnotic, state is only a form of dreaming.’

Neumann argues that the participation mystique characterising the group psyche represents not regression from waking consciousness but the primordial condition from which individual consciousness has yet to differentiate.

Neumann, Erich, The Origins and History of Consciousness (Princeton, 2019thesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

What characterizes the hypnotist who is hypnotized by the unconscious is the banality of his mind… if completely swamped by the invading content, consciousness becomes incapable of taking up any counterposition whatsoever, but is carried away and possessed by it to the point of identification.

Neumann distinguishes the Great Individual — whose consciousness actively engages unconscious contents — from the leader swamped by unconscious participation, reduced to a mere mouthpiece of the collective unconscious.

Neumann, Erich, The Origins and History of Consciousness (Princeton, 2019thesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

the primitive has not yet experienced that ascetic discipline of mind known to us as the critique of knowledge. To him the world is a more or less fluid phenomenon within the stream of his own fantasy, where subject and object are undifferentiated and in a state of mutual interpenetration.

Jung describes the phenomenology of unconscious participation as a pre-critical condition in which the psyche’s fantasies and projections constitute the fabric of experienced reality.

Jung, Carl Gustav, The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious, 1959supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Unconscious actions are always taken for granted and are therefore not critically evaluated. One is then surprised at the incomprehensible reactions of one’s neighbours, whom one holds to be responsible; that is, one fails to see what one does oneself.

Jung traces the social pathology of projection — blaming others for one’s own unconscious acts — directly to the failure of self-knowledge that sustains unconscious participation.

Jung, C.G., Collected Works Volume 18: The Symbolic Life, 1976supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

the submersion of the individual in the group and of ego consciousness in the unconscious… The passivity of the individual in relation to the herd is to some extent a condition of the herd’s activity.

Neumann, drawing on crowd psychology, shows that unconscious participation within the group requires the suppression of individual ego-consciousness as its structural precondition.

Neumann, Erich, The Origins and History of Consciousness (Princeton, 2019supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

the emotional reactions of empathy manifested in the earlier developmental stages are largely based on projection and have little to do with an objective evaluation of what is happening.

Stein observes that the empathic resonances associated with earlier developmental stages are themselves expressions of projection-based participation rather than genuinely objective response.

Stein, Murray, Jung’s Map of the Soul: An Introduction, 1998supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

the participation of deeper layers of the mind, in particular, the participation of unconscious fantasy, and associated levels of unconscious anxiety… a psychological factor that would honor the fact that it is not trauma that splits the psyche, but a feared meaning of trauma to the individual.

Kalsched shows that Freud’s revision of the seduction theory introduced unconscious fantasy participation as the psychic co-determinant of neurosis, moving beyond purely external traumatic causation.

Kalsched, Donald, The Inner World of Trauma: Archetypal Defences of the Personal Spirit, 1996supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

she can begin to take a part in the fantasy, that is, she can ‘get into’ the fantasy and participate in its development, instead of merely being obsessed by the mood of unhappiness into which such a disappointment is only too apt to throw her.

Harding distinguishes unconscious obsession — a passive form of participation — from active imaginative engagement, in which a woman consciously enters and shapes the emerging fantasy rather than being driven by it.

Harding, Esther, the way of all women, 1970supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

The process of reconciliation occurs through conscious participation in symbols which emerge from the unconscious and bring together the two opposing poles in a third form.

Woodman frames psychic healing as the shift from unconscious to conscious participation in symbols, through which the ego moves from passive possession to active co-creation with the unconscious.

Woodman, Marion, The Owl Was a Baker’s Daughter: Obesity, Anorexia Nervosa and the Repressed Feminine: a Psychological Study, 1980supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Jung emphasizes the necessity of relating to patients from one’s whole personality… the passages in his writings that recommend this participation are largely in didactic, exhortatory form.

Edinger notes that Jung’s call for the analyst’s full personal participation in the therapeutic encounter implicitly counters the risk of unconscious, unexamined participation on both sides of the analytic dyad.

Edinger, Edward F., Science of the Soul: A Jungian Perspective, 2002aside

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

he had noticed the smell subliminally, and this unconscious perception had called back long-forgotten memories.

Jung illustrates unconscious participation at the perceptual level, where subliminal environmental stimuli silently activate memory and fantasy below the threshold of awareness.

Jung, Carl Gustav, Man and His Symbols, 1964aside

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Related terms