Substance Use Disorder

Substance Use Disorder (SUD) occupies a contested and richly theorized position within the depth-psychology corpus, where it functions simultaneously as a diagnostic category, a symptomatic expression of inner suffering, and a site of co-occurring psychopathology. The literature reveals three broad orientational stances. First, the psychodynamic self-medication tradition, represented most forcefully by Edward Khantzian, understands SUD not as a primary disease of willpower or pharmacological hijacking alone, but as a purposive—if ultimately self-defeating—attempt to regulate painful affects, manage ego deficits, and ameliorate psychiatric symptoms that otherwise render life intolerable. Second, the integrated-treatment tradition, exemplified by Lisa Najavits’s Seeking Safety framework, insists that SUD cannot be adequately treated in isolation from co-occurring trauma disorders; the intertwining of PTSD and substance use demands simultaneous clinical attention rather than sequential hierarchy. Third, a growing body of comorbidity research examines SUD in relation to neurodevelopmental conditions—ADHD and Autism Spectrum Disorder in particular—challenging any single-axis etiological model. Across all positions, the corpus foregrounds ambivalence, denial, the compulsion to repeat, nutritional depletion, and the long-term costs disguised by short-term relief as central clinical and theoretical concerns. The diagnostic taxonomy itself—abuse versus dependence, DSM-IV versus DSM-5—surfaces as a recurring methodological tension.

In the library

patients are knowingly and unknowingly governed by other motives… they actively and often knowingly perpetuate their suffering when they compulsively continue to use drugs or when they relapse after periods of abstinence.

Khantzian argues that SUD is driven by the compulsion to repeat unresolved developmental pain, not merely by pharmacological dependence, constituting the foundational claim of the self-medication hypothesis.

Khantzian, Edward J., The Self-Medication Hypothesis of Substance Use Disorders: A Reconsideration and Recent Applications, 1997thesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

most of the anxiety and depression associated with substance use disorders is the consequence of chronic use and clears over time with abstinence.

Khantzian acknowledges the counter-argument — advanced by Vaillant and Schuckit — that psychiatric comorbidity in SUD is largely iatrogenic rather than etiological, marking a central tension in the field.

Khantzian, Edward J., The Self-Medication Hypothesis of Substance Use Disorders: A Reconsideration and Recent Applications, 1997thesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

No matter how much substances make something better in the short term, they always make things worse in the long term. They decrease physical, emotional, and spiritual health.

Najavits positions the distinction between short-term relief and long-term deterioration as the organizing clinical principle for treating SUD concurrent with PTSD.

Najavits, Lisa M., Seeking Safety: A Treatment Manual for PTSD and Substance Abuse, 2002thesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Some patients need a review of substance use disorder criteria. These include those who (1) are in denial about the impact of their substance use, despite clear evidence of a serious problem.

Najavits identifies denial, diagnostic ambiguity, and contradictory messages from clinicians as the primary obstacles to a patient’s recognition of SUD severity.

Najavits, Lisa M., Seeking Safety: A Treatment Manual for PTSD and Substance Abuse, 2002thesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

If any three above are true for you, you would be diagnosed with substance dependence, which you can remember by the acronym ‘QUIT NOW.’

Najavits operationalizes DSM criteria for substance abuse and dependence in patient-accessible language, emphasizing tolerance, loss of control, and withdrawal as the diagnostic threshold for dependence.

Najavits, Lisa M., Seeking Safety: A Treatment Manual for PTSD and Substance Abuse, 2002supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Patients with substance use (SUD) and posttraumatic stress disorders (PTSD) are at high risk for relapse. This study examined the reasons patients identify for their first substance use following discharge from SUD treatment.

Ouimette establishes that the PTSD-SUD comorbidity creates a specifically elevated relapse risk, framing post-treatment substance use as precipitant-driven rather than random.

Ouimette, Paige, Precipitants of first substance use in recently abstinent substance use disorder patients with PTSD, 2007thesis

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

About half of the patients seeking treatment for substance use disorder (SUD) drop out before finishing the treatment… there is a need to develop individualized treatments for the different subgroups that do not feel the effect of regular drug treatment programs.

Arnevik situates SUD treatment dropout as a structural problem demanding subgroup differentiation, with ASD co-occurrence as an underexamined contributor to treatment failure.

Arnevik, Eli A., Autism Spectrum Disorder and Co-occurring Substance Use Disorder: A Systematic Review, 2016supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

About half of the patients seeking treatment for substance use disorder (SUD) drop out before finishing the treatment… one patient group that may be in need of special attention, but has been little studied, is that of individuals with co-occurring autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and SUD.

This parallel systematic review reinforces the case that neurodevelopmental comorbidity constitutes a neglected moderator of SUD treatment outcomes.

Arnevik, Einar A., Substance Use Disorders in People with Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Systematic Review, 2016supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

the premise is examined that malnutrition may promote drug seeking and impede recovery from substance use disorders (SUD).

Jeynes advances a biopsychological argument that nutritional deficiency is not merely a sequela of SUD but an active impediment to recovery, broadening the etiological frame beyond psychology alone.

Jeynes, Kendall D., The importance of nutrition in aiding recovery from substance use disorders: A review, 2012supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Unhealthy alcohol use is the third leading preventable cause of death in the United States, accounting for more than 140,000 deaths annually.

McPheeters establishes the epidemiological scale of alcohol use disorder as a public health emergency, providing the population-level context within which individual-focused depth-psychological approaches must operate.

McPheeters, Melissa, Pharmacotherapy for Adults With Alcohol Use Disorder in Outpatient Settings: Systematic Review, 2023supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

A maladaptive pattern of alcohol use leading to clinically significant impairment or distress… Recurrent alcohol use resulting in a failure to fulfill major role obligations at work, school, or home.

McPheeters reproduces DSM-IV alcohol abuse criteria alongside DSM-5 definitions, foregrounding the diagnostic evolution from categorical abuse/dependence to a unified severity spectrum.

McPheeters, Melissa, Pharmacotherapy for Adults With Alcohol Use Disorder in Outpatient Settings: Systematic Review, 2023supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

tremendous distress, suffering, and dysfunction are associated with negative symptoms, and it should not be surprising that patients with these symptoms find that the specific effects of the various classes of abused drugs can alter, ameliorate, or relieve their pain.

Khantzian extends the self-medication hypothesis to schizophrenic negative symptoms, arguing that drug choice reflects the specific psychobiological relief each substance class affords.

Khantzian, Edward J., The Self-Medication Hypothesis of Substance Use Disorders: A Reconsideration and Recent Applications, 1997supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Substance abuse is known to evoke enormous countertransference in therapists, including power struggles, boredom, cynicism, indifference, blaming, withdrawal, burnout.

Najavits draws attention to therapist countertransference as a clinically significant variable in SUD treatment, noting that negative reactions intensify over time even with specialized training.

Najavits, Lisa M., Seeking Safety: A Treatment Manual for PTSD and Substance Abuse, 2002supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Both disorders require long-term treatment and involve multiple parts and levels of both specialized treatment facilities and support in the primary health services.

Arnevik highlights the structural and financial barriers to developing evidence-based interventions for the ASD-SUD comorbidity, underlining the gap between clinical need and research investment.

Arnevik, Eli A., Autism Spectrum Disorder and Co-occurring Substance Use Disorder: A Systematic Review, 2016supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

those who have been addicted can not only recover, but thrive and develop. An important question is why this should be so and how it comes about. It goes against the common assumption that the outcome for addicted people is inevitably hopeless.

Addenbrooke challenges deterministic prognoses for SUD by centering survivor narratives, foregrounding resilience and long-term recovery as empirically documented but theoretically underexplained phenomena.

Addenbrooke, Mary, Survivors of Addiction: Narratives of Recovery, 2011supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

there is no free substance use. Both emotionally and financially, substance use has a cost. Using may feel good for a few minutes or hours, but you’ll pay the cost later.

Najavits employs a cost-accounting metaphor to make the long-term consequences of SUD cognitively accessible to patients, integrating interpersonal, financial, and emotional registers.

Najavits, Lisa M., Seeking Safety: A Treatment Manual for PTSD and Substance Abuse, 2002supporting

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

An Examination of Mindfulness-Based Experiences Through Adventure in Substance Use Disorder Treatment for Young Adult Males: a Pilot Study

Russell introduces adventure-based mindfulness as an emerging adjunctive intervention modality for SUD treatment in young adult males, signaling a somatic and experiential turn in the field.

Russell, Keith C., An Examination of Mindfulness-Based Experiences Through Adventure in Substance Use Disorder Treatment for Young Adult Males: a Pilot Study, 2016aside

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Addiction refers to a behavioral pattern of cultural abuse characterized by overwhelming involvement with obtaining and using a drug. The drug pervades the life of the user.

Flores traces the contested terminological history of SUD-adjacent concepts — habituation, compulsive abuse, addiction — noting pharmacologists’ strategic avoidance of ‘addiction’ in favor of ‘drug dependence.’

Flores, Philip J, Group Psychotherapy with Addicted Populations An, 1997aside

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Comorbidity of ADHD and substance-use disorder (SUD): a neuroimaging perspective.

Wilens situates the ADHD-SUD comorbidity within a neuroimaging framework, suggesting that shared neurobiological substrates — rather than secondary self-medication alone — underlie their frequent co-occurrence.

Wilens, Timothy E, Substance-use disorders in adolescents and adults with ADHD: focus on treatment, 2012aside

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Is it essential to get ‘clean’ from substances before working on PTSD?… What is ‘self-medication’?… What are ways to deal with trauma memories early in substance abuse treatment?

Najavits identifies the sequencing question — whether sobriety must precede trauma work — as a principal source of confusion for patients navigating dual-diagnosis recovery.

Najavits, Lisa M., Seeking Safety: A Treatment Manual for PTSD and Substance Abuse, 2002aside

Dig deeper with Sebastian →

Related terms