The concordance 21 witnesses
Orientation
An Orphic book, part of which survives, was burnt at a Greek burial: Walter Burkert cites that grave, with the gold leaves and the Derveni papyrus, as evidence that Bacchic mysteries promising blessedness in the afterlife existed by the fifth century at the latest. Yet Burkert records Plato’s scorn for wandering mystery-priests peddling books of Orpheus and Musaios and sacrificing according to them; the tradition was profound and disreputable at once. Erwin Rohde located its doctrinal heart in the Zagreus myth, read as the aetiology of the ritual dismemberment of the bull-god at Bacchic nocturnal festivals, a rite derived from the god’s legendary sufferings. E.R. Dodds found it hard to distinguish an Orphic from a Pythagorean psychology, since both avoided meat, practiced catharsis, and viewed the body as a prison. Jane Ellen Harrison heard protest in the gold-tablet avowal ‘my race is of Heaven alone,’ a counter-creed of celestial parentage. Richard Seaford reads the myth of Zeus’s swallowing and Dionysus’s reconstitution as the victory of unity over fragmentation in cosmos and self; the egg-hatched Phanes, first of the gods, returns in Jung’s Red Book as a visionary figure.
its purpose is to explain the religious implication of the ritual dismemberment of the bull-god at the Bacchic nocturnal festivals, and to derive that feature from the legendary sufferings of Dionysos-Zagreus
Rohde identifies the aetiological function of the Orphic Zagreus myth as the doctrinal heart of Orphism, linking ritual practice to cosmological narrative.
, Psyche: The Cult of Souls and the Belief in Immortality among the Greeks, 1894thesis
I find it hard to distinguish an ‘Orphic’ from a ‘Pythagorean’ psychology; for Pythagoreans too are said to have avoided meat, practised catharsis, and viewed the body as a prison
Dodds argues that the boundary between Orphic and Pythagorean doctrine is historically indeterminate, undermining the notion of a coherent, separable Orphic school.
, The Greeks and the Irrational, 1951thesis
Wandering mystery priests appealed to the books of Orpheus… they offer a bundle of books of Musaios and Orpheus… according to which they perform their sacrifices
Burkert documents Plato’s critical portrait of Orpheotelestai as itinerant ritualists who commercialised Orphic texts, revealing the socially ambiguous status of Orphic practice.
, Greek Religion: Archaic and Classical, 1977thesis
The avowal of the initiate Orphic does not end here. A second clause is added, not wholly untinged, I think, by protest: But my race is of Heaven (alone).
Harrison reads the gold-tablet formula as a deliberate Orphic counter-creed asserting celestial over earthly or Olympian parentage.
, Themis: A Study of the Social Origins of Greek Religion, 1912thesis
In the Orphic theogony, Aither and Chaos are born from Chronos. Chronos makes an egg in Aither. The egg splits into two, and Phanes, the first of the Gods, appears.
The editorial commentary to the Red Book maps the Orphic Phanes cosmogony onto Jung’s visionary figure, establishing the theogonic tradition as a template for depth-psychological symbolism.
, The Red Book: Liber Novus, 2009thesis
The same motif is also found in some Orphic texts. The origin of the Orphic traditions and mysteries is not very clear to us historically. It precedes the birth of Greek philosophy, and we have to date it between the eighth and sixth century BC.
Von Franz situates the Orphic cosmogonic egg within a comparative mythological framework, treating Orphism as an archaic cosmological substrate anteceding Greek philosophy.
, Creation Myths, 1995thesis
by the fifth century at the latest there are Bacchic mysteries which promise blessedness in the afterlife… at another burial at the same place an Orphic book, part of which is preserved, was burnt
Burkert uses the Derveni papyrus and gold-leaf finds to confirm the early historical intersection of Bacchic and Orphic eschatological practice.
, Greek Religion: Archaic and Classical, 1977supporting
Orphic myth enacts the victory of unity over fragmentation in both cosmos and self
Seaford reads the Orphic mythology of Zeus’s swallowing and Dionysus’s reconstitution as a cosmological allegory of unified selfhood overcoming dispersal.
, Money and the Early Greek Mind: Homer, Philosophy, Tragedy, 2004supporting
Aristotle also writes that it was stated ‘in the so-called Orphic poems’ that the soul, being borne by the winds from out of the universe, enters a living creature with its first breath
Burkert cites Aristotle to establish that Orphic pneumatic soul-doctrine was recognised as a discrete tradition in antiquity, though Aristotle’s phrasing already signals scholarly reserve.
, Greek Religion: Archaic and Classical, 1977supporting
To attribute the practical side of Orphism to a late degeneration of the once purely speculative character of the sect is a very arbitrary proceeding and quite unjustifiable on historical grounds.
Rohde defends the antiquity of Orphic ritual practice against scholars who reduce early Orphism to pure theology, insisting on the co-originality of its practical and speculative dimensions.
, Psyche: The Cult of Souls and the Belief in Immortality among the Greeks, 1894supporting
the devouring of the heart of Zagreus may perhaps belong to the older Orphic legendary material, the devouring of Phanes to the later
Rohde attempts a stratigraphic analysis of Orphic myth, distinguishing archaic Zagreus material from later Phanes theology in the Rhapsodic Theogony.
, Psyche: The Cult of Souls and the Belief in Immortality among the Greeks, 1894supporting
The exact nature of this ‘guilt’ of the soul is not explained in our remains of Orphic literature. The point, however, is chiefly that the life within the body is according to their doctrine not in accordance with but contrary to the proper nature of the soul.
Rohde identifies the Orphic concept of somatic existence as fundamentally alien to the soul’s true nature, locating the soteriological urgency of Orphic eschatology.
, Psyche: The Cult of Souls and the Belief in Immortality among the Greeks, 1894supporting
Pythagoras himself is mentioned among the writers of Orphic poems in the Tetragrammoi of Ion
Rohde surveys ancient attributions of Orphic authorship to Pythagorean figures, corroborating the difficulty of separating the two movements.
, Psyche: The Cult of Souls and the Belief in Immortality among the Greeks, 1894supporting
They were as clearly conscious as was Herakleitos of the fact that autos ‘Aidns kai Dionusos, whereas this consciousness was undoubtedly
Rohde traces the Orphic identification of Hades and Dionysus, linking chthonic and Bacchic theology in the figure of Zagreus-Dionysus.
, Psyche: The Cult of Souls and the Belief in Immortality among the Greeks, 1894supporting
The establishment in later Orphic poetry of the theory that the psychai dwelt in the air may have been assisted by the philosophic theory of the soaring-up of the pneumata into their element the aether
Rohde documents the late Orphic transfer of soul-geography from underworld to air and aether, tracing a convergence of Orphic and Stoic cosmological speculation.
, Psyche: The Cult of Souls and the Belief in Immortality among the Greeks, 1894supporting
Robert Romanyshyn, ‘Anyway, Why Did it have to be the Poet: The Orphic Roots of Jung’s Psychology,’ Spring 71 (2004): 55-87.
Romanyshyn situates Orphic mythology as a generative source for Jung’s depth psychology, directly linking the poetic-shamanic Orphic tradition to analytic theory.
, The Wounded Researcher: Research with Soul in Mind, 2007supporting
Orphic fragments, 130n / Orphic hymns, 516 / Orphic mysteries, see mysteries / Orphism, 136n
The index of Mysterium Coniunctionis confirms Jung’s sustained but dispersed engagement with Orphic fragments, hymns, and mysteries as alchemical and psychological parallels.
, Mysterium Coniunctionis: An Inquiry into the Separation and Synthesis of Psychic Opposites in Alchemy, 1955supporting
Transmigration of Souls — Greek names for, x, 84; Thracian belief in, 263 f.; Egyptian belief in, 346; Orphic, 337; 342 f.; 346 f.; Pythagorean, 375
Rohde’s index places Orphic transmigration doctrine within a comparative framework alongside Thracian, Egyptian, and Pythagorean parallels.
, Psyche: The Cult of Souls and the Belief in Immortality among the Greeks, 1894supporting
Orphic cult of Bakchos, x, 1; poetry, authorship of, x, 7; Rhapsodical Theogony, ix, 123; 339-40; 596 f.; other Theogonies, x, 21; origin of mankind in, 389
Rohde’s index provides a systematic topography of Orphic themes, confirming the breadth of his treatment across theogony, anthropogony, cult, and eschatology.
, Psyche: The Cult of Souls and the Belief in Immortality among the Greeks, 1894supporting
Wilamowitz advocated extreme scepticism towards everything ‘Orphic’, GdH II 182-204, followed by Linforth, Moulinier, Zuntz.
Burkert’s bibliographic note registers the influential Wilamowitzian sceptical tradition regarding the historical coherence of Orphism.
, Greek Religion: Archaic and Classical, 1977aside
There is in my judgement a stronger case for attaching Empedocles to the Pythagorean tradition than for connecting him with anything that is demonstrably and distinctively early-Orphic
Dodds positions Empedocles closer to Pythagoreanism than to demonstrable early Orphism, illustrating the scholarly difficulty of assigning thinkers to the Orphic category.
, The Greeks and the Irrational, 1951aside