Mount Zion appears in the depth-psychology corpus not as a mere toponym but as a charged symbolic locus that condenses several overlapping axes of meaning: the sacred Center, the heavenly archetype of the earthly city, the tension between literal geography and imaginal geography, and the eschatological horizon of a renewed cosmos. Eliade situates Zion within his broadest comparative framework—the Sacred Mountain as axis mundi where heaven and earth communicate—while noting that Jerusalem, the Temple, and Palestine itself constitute concentric repetitions of the same cosmological center. Edinger, reading through a Jungian lens, treats Zion as the positive pole of a symbolic dyad opposed to Babylon, making it a psychic image of the sacred city as against the profane city of captivity. Thielman, working from a canonical-theological perspective, reads Mount Zion typologically: the Lamb standing on Zion in Revelation recapitulates Psalm 68's triumphant ascent of the Lord, and the heavenly Zion of Hebrews 12 displaces the earthly Sinai as the site of eschatological covenant. Hillman introduces the sharpest critical edge, diagnosing the fusion of the mythic-imaginal Zion with actual geographic territory as a primary driver of historical violence. Armstrong locates Zion at the origin of secular Zionism, tracing how a fundamentally religious symbol was conscripted into modern nationalist politics. These voices collectively illuminate why Mount Zion remains one of the most contested symbols in the Western religious imagination.
This merging of religious vision and physical geography in the Hebrew word for earth is a cause of the greatest trouble.
Hillman argues that the conflation of the imaginal Zion with literal geographic territory—encoded in the Hebrew 'Am ha-aretz—is the root of profound and ongoing political violence.
, Mythic Figures, 2007thesis
By the rivers of Babylon, there we sat down, yea, we wept, when we remembered Zion [Zion means Jerusalem].
Edinger reads Zion as the sacred pole of a fundamental symbolic opposition between the holy city and the city of captivity, a dyad that structures both the Hebrew scriptures and the Book of Revelation.
, Transformation of the God-Image: An Elucidation of Jung's Answer to Job, 1992thesis
this psalm describes the triumphant ascent of the Lord to the top of Mount Zion after making captives of his enemies.
Thielman shows how Paul reads Psalm 68's triumphal ascent of Mount Zion as a type of Christ's victorious ascension and distribution of gifts to the church.
, Theology of the New Testament: A Canonical and Synthetic Approach, 2005thesis
To show him the city of Jerusalem, God lays hold of Ezekiel in an ecstatic vision and transports him to a very high mountain.
Eliade reads the prophetic transport to a high mountain to behold Jerusalem as evidence that Zion functions as the Sacred Mountain, the celestial archetype that every earthly temple replicates.
, The Myth of the Eternal Return: Cosmos and History, 1954supporting
Palestine, Jerusalem, and the Temple severally and concurrently represent the image of the universe and the Center of the World.
Eliade establishes that Zion/Jerusalem participates in a nested series of cosmological centers, each of which is a complete imago mundi.
, The Sacred and the Profane: The Nature of Religion, 1957supporting
The yearning for the return to Zion (one of the chief hills of Jerusalem) began as a defiantly secular movement, since the vicissitudes of history had convinced the Zionists that their religion and their God did not work.
Armstrong traces how the sacred symbol of Zion was secularized and politicized into modern nationalist ideology, producing a movement explicitly estranged from its own religious origins.
, A History of God, 1993supporting
tunc omnis, qui relictus fuerit in Sion salvus vocabitur, cum abluerit Dominus sordem filiarum suarum Sion spiritu sapientiae et intellectus
Von Franz's alchemical text deploys Zion as the eschatological locus of salvific purification, linking the daughters of Zion to the spirit of wisdom and understanding in a soteriological framework.
, Aurora Consurgens: A Document Attributed to Thomas Aquinas on the Problem of Opposites in Alchemy, 1966supporting
Mount Tabor, in Palestine, might signify tabbur, that is, 'navel,' omphalos. Mount Gerizim, at the center of Palestine, was doubtless invested with the prestige of the 'Center,' for it is called 'navel of the earth.'
Eliade contextualizes Palestinian sacred mountains, including those near Zion, within the universal symbolism of the omphalos, confirming their function as world-navels and cosmic axes.
, Shamanism: Archaic Techniques of Ecstasy, 1951supporting
no fewer than three of the most important world-religions — the Jewish, the Christian, and the Islamic — Jerusalem has ever been a holy place
Rank notes in passing that Jerusalem's sacred status across three world religions reflects the omphalos idea's enduring hold on the human imagination.
, Art and Artist: Creative Urge and Personality Development, 1932aside
The Sacred Mountain—where heaven and earth meet—is situated at the center of the world. Every temple or palace—and, by extension, every sacred city or royal residence—is a Sacred Mountain, thus becoming a Center.
Eliade's general theory of the Sacred Mountain as axis mundi provides the cosmological framework within which Mount Zion's symbolic function is to be understood.
, The Myth of the Eternal Return: Cosmos and History, 1954aside