The concordance 15 witnesses
Orientation
A patient dreams he is led through a circumcision rite into manhood, and Jung reads this as the cure for his homosexuality: a childish condition to be initiated out of, not a fixed identity to be affirmed. That diagnostic instinct sits uneasily beside Jung’s other verdict, recorded by James Hillman, that anima-identification in a homosexual man “should not be adjudged negative in all circumstances,” since it may preserve something of the archetype of the Original Man. Jung further separated pathological homosexuality, marked by an incapacity for real friendship, from the “rapturous friendship” of ordinary young men, refusing a single clinical picture. Freud had already declined to isolate homosexual persons as a class at all, arguing in the Three Essays that unconscious object-choice ranges across sexes in everyone; Karl Abraham then supplied the mechanism, tracing same-sex attraction to introjection of the opposite-sex parent. Andrew Samuels notes analytical psychology’s long silence on the subject, neither pathologizing it biologically nor theorizing it on its own terms, a gap Renos Papadopoulos shows later analysts closing: citing Springer, he argues a homosexual life can constitute successful individuation, unsettling the anima/animus scaffolding itself.
psycho-analysis considers that a choice of an object independently of its sex — freedom to range equally over male and female objects — as it is found in childhood… is the original basis from which
Freud argues that psychoanalysis opposes any segregation of homosexuals as a special class, positing instead that all human beings are capable of homosexual object-choice and have made one in their unconscious.
, Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality, 1905thesis
Homosexuality has received little attention in analytical psychology. So far as I know there has never been a suggestion that homosexuality is either a mental illness or biologically determined.
Samuels surveys the post-Jungian field and notes analytical psychology’s consistent refusal to pathologize homosexuality medically or biologically, while acknowledging the topic’s relative neglect.
, Jung and the Post-Jungians, 1985thesis
Springer views a feminine homosexual development as a successful mode of living, an example of successful individuation, and not necessarily as a pathological development, even when the animus has not been experienced in a sexual relationship with a man.
Papadopoulos surveys post-Jungian revisions — especially Springer and Hopcke — that reframe homosexual development as a viable path of individuation and challenge the contrasexual anima/animus construct.
, The Handbook of Jungian Psychology: Theory, Practice and Applications, 2006thesis
homosexuality, which is usually characterized by identity with the anima…. Such a disposition should not be adjudged negative in all circumstances, in so far as it preserves the archetype of the Original Man.
Citing Jung directly, Hillman records the view that homosexuality involves anima-identity but cautions against purely negative evaluation, since it may preserve a primordial archetypal wholeness.
, Anima: An Anatomy of a Personified Notion, 1985thesis
a man is capable of believing that he actually is homosexual, in spite of the fact that he never had the experience… This simply means that the man in certain respects is not mature.
Jung distinguishes between symbolic and literal homosexuality, arguing that dream-based or imagined homosexuality often signifies psychological immaturity rather than a definitive sexual orientation.
, Dream Analysis: Notes of the Seminar Given in 1928-1930, 1984thesis
The complaint to be remedied is homosexuality. The dreamer is to be led out of this relatively childish condition and initiated into the adult state by means of a kind of circumcision ceremony under the supervision of a priest.
Jung reads a patient’s homosexuality as a stage of psychological immaturity to be transcended through archetypal initiation, framing the relationship symbolically as a developmental problem.
, The Development of Personality, 1954thesis
I am speaking here not of pathological homosexuals who are incapable of real friendship and meet with little sympathy among normal individuals, but of more or less normal youngsters who enjoy such a rapturous friendship.
Jung distinguishes between what he calls pathological homosexuality and normative same-sex emotional intimacy among young people, implying a spectrum rather than a single clinical category.
, Civilization in Transition, 1964supporting
a young man will feel an inclination towards male persons because he has assimilated his mother by means of a psychological process of incorporation and consequently reacts to male objects in the way that she would do.
Abraham expounds Freud’s etiology of homosexuality through introjection of the opposite-sex parent, situating same-sex attraction within the broader psychoanalytic theory of identification and object-choice.
, Selected Papers on Psychoanalysis, 1927supporting
it does not seem right to refer to friendships of either character by a term which is linked in the mind of the public with debased practices and criminality, for they are often of a high moral and ethical quality.
Harding contests the stigmatizing connotations of the term ‘homosexuality’ when applied to women’s intimate friendships, arguing that the instinctual-erotic dimension does not preclude high ethical quality.
, the way of all women, 1970supporting
we are bound, in fact, to regard the choice of an object of the same sex as a regular type of off-shoot of the capacity to love, and are learning every day more and more to recognize it as especially important.
Freud presents homosexual object-choice as a normal variant of erotic capacity while also linking the suppression of homosexual tendencies to the genesis of paranoia.
, Introductory Lectures on Psycho-Analysis, 1917supporting
I think there is some relationship between the archetype of the puer and male homosexuality, and it probably lies in the flight of the puer away from the instinctual world of the Great Mother.
Liz Greene proposes an archetypal connection between the puer aeternus constellation and male homosexuality, framing it as a flight from the instinctual feminine rather than as a fixed pathology.
, The Development of Personality: Seminars in Psychological Astrology, Volume 1, 1987supporting
I am in a great Gothic cathedral. At the altar stands a priest. I stand before him with my friend… Suddenly an elderly woman appears, takes the fraternity ring from my friend’s finger, and puts it on her own.
Jung analyses a dream series in which the fraternity ring symbolizes a homosexual bond, interpreting the appearance of the elderly woman as the psyche’s compensatory movement toward heterosexual relatedness.
, Two Essays on Analytical Psychology, 1953supporting
Friendship with women and homosexuality may then be based on idealization of the second object, the father’s penis and the father, may then be more successful.
Klein situates female homosexuality within the early object-relations matrix, linking it to idealization of the paternal object as a resolution of ambivalence toward the mother.
, Envy and Gratitude and Other Works 1946-1963, 1957supporting
If its sexual interest is directed outwards to another person, it makes but little difference to the child what that person’s sex is. Hence the child may very easily be ‘homosexual.’
In summarizing Freudian theory, Jung notes the child’s pre-genital polymorphous sexuality as the developmental ground from which homosexual orientation may later emerge.
, Collected Works Volume 1: Psychiatric Studies, 1902aside
the example of the passive homosexual, looks equally unfair. The reason this person’s sexual activity is seen by the interlocutors as unfortunate is, even within their point of view, in large part a social and cultural reason.
Nussbaum, in her reading of Plato, notes that the negative valuation of passive homosexual experience in the ancient world is culturally rather than morally grounded, contextualizing depth psychology’s classical inheritance.
, The Fragility of Goodness: Luck and Ethics in Greek Tragedy and Philosophy, 1986aside